Evaluation of a Non-Targeted “Omic” Approach in the Safety Assessment of Genetically Modified Plants

Abstract

Genetically modified plants must be approved before release in the European Union, and the approval is generally based upon a comparison of various characteristics between the transgenic plant and a conventional counterpart. As a case study, focusing on safety assessment of genetically modified plants, we here report the development and characterisation of six independently transformed Arabidopsis thaliana lines modified in the flavonoid biosynthesis. Analyses of integration events and comparative analysis for characterisation of the intended effects were performed by PCR, quantitative Real-time PCR, and High Performance Liquid Chromatography. Analysis by cDNA microarray was used as a non-targeted approach for the identification of potential unintended effects caused by the transformation. The results revealed that, although the transgenic lines possessed different types of integration events, no unintended effects were identified. However, we found that the majority of genes showing differential expression were identified as stress-related genes and that environmental conditions had a large impact on the expression of several genes, proteins, and metabolites. We suggest that the microarray approach has the potential to become a useful tool for screening of unintended effects, but state that it is crucial to have substantial information on the natural variation in traditional crops in order to be able to interpret “omics” data correctly within the framework of food safety assessment strategies of novel plant varieties, including genetically modified plant varieties.

Key words

Transgenic crops - gene insertion studies - gene expression - intended and unintended effects - safety assessment.

References

• 1 Alonso J. M., Stepanova A. N., Leisse T. J., Kim C. J., Chen H., Shinn P., Stevenson D. K., Zimmerman J., Barajas P., Cheuk R., Gadrinab C., Heller C., Jeske A., Koesema E., Meyers C. C., Parker H., Prednis L., Ansari Y., Choy N., Deen H., Geralt M., Hazari N., Hom E., Karnes M., Mulholland C., Ndubaku R., Schmidt I., Guzman P., Aguilar-Henonin L., Schmid M., Weigel D., Carter D. E., Marchand T., Risseeuw E., Brogden D., Zeko A., Crosby W. L., Berry C. C., Ecker J. R.. Genome-wide insertional mutagenesis of Arabidopsis thaliana.  Science. (2003);  301 653-657
• 2 Balzergue S., Dubreucq B., Chauvin S., Le-Clainche I., Le Boulaire F., de Rose R., Samson F., Biaudet V., Lecharny A., Cruaud C., Weissenbach J., Caboche M., Lepiniec L.. Improved PCR-walking for large-scale isolation of plant T‐DNA borders.  Biotechniques. (2001);  30 496-504
• 3 Berger S., Mitchell-Olds T., Stotz H. U.. Local and differential control of vegetative storage protein expression in response to herbivore damage in Arabidopsis thaliana.  Physiologia Plantarum. (2002);  114 85-91
• 4 Booij-James I. S., Dube S. K., Jansen M. A., Edelman M., Mattoo A. K.. Ultraviolet-B radiation impacts light-mediated turnover of the photosystem II reaction center heterodimer in Arabidopsis mutants altered in phenolic metabolism.  Plant Physiology. (2000);  124 1275-1284
• 5 Bray E. A.. Classification of genes differentially expressed during water-deficit stress in Arabidopsis thaliana: an analysis using microarray and differential expression data.  Annals of Botany. (2002);  89 803-811
• 6 Brazma A.. On the importance of standardisation in life sciences.  Bioinformatics. (2001);  17 113-114
• 7 Brazma A., Hingamp P., Quackenbush J., Sherlock G., Spellman P., Stoeckert C., Aach J., Ansorge W., Ball C. A., Causton H. C., Gaasterland T., Glenisson P., Holstege F. C., Kim I. F., Markowitz V., Matese J. C., Parkinson H., Robinson A., Sarkans U., Schulze-Kremer S., Stewart J., Taylor R., Vilo J., Vingron M.. Minimum information about a microarray experiment (MIAME)-toward standards for microarray data.  Nature Genetics. (2001);  29 365-371
• 8 Brunaud V., Balzergue S., Dubreucq B., Aubourg S., Samson F., Chauvin S., Bechtold N., Cruaud C., DeRose R., Pelletier G., Lepiniec L., Caboche M., Lecharney A.. T‐DNA integration into the Arabidopsis genome depends on sequences of pre-insertion sites.  EMBO Reports. (2002);  3 1152-1157
• 9 Cellini F., Chesson A., Colquhoun I. J., Constable A., Davies H. V., Engel K. H., Gatehouse A. M. R., Kärenlampi S., Kok E. J., Leguay J. J., Lehesranta S., Noteborn H. P. J. M., Pedersen J., Smith M.. Unintended effects and their detection in genetically modified crops.  Food and Chemical Toxicology. (2004);  42 1089-1125
• 10 Clough S. J., Bent A. F.. Floral dip: a simplified method for Agrobacterium-mediated transformation of Arabidopsis thaliana.  The Plant Journal. (1998);  16 735-743
• 12 Cos P., De Bruyne T., Hermans N., Apers S., Berghe D. V., Vlietinck A. J.. Proanthocyanidins in health care: current and new trends.  Current Medicinal Chemistry. (2004);  11 1345-1359
• 13 Dandekar A. M., Teo G., Defilippi B. G., Uratsu S. L., Passey A. J., Kader A. A., Stow J. R., Colgan R. J., James D. J.. Effect of down-regulation of ethylene biosynthesis on fruit flavour complex in apple fruit.  Transgenic Research. (2004);  13 373-384
• 14 De Buck S., Jacobs A., Van Montagu M., Depicker A.. The DNA sequences of T‐DNA junctions suggest that complex T‐DNA loci are formed by a recombination process resembling T‐DNA integration.  The Plant Journal. (1999);  20 295-304
• 15 De Neve M., De Buck S., Jacobs A., Van Montagu M., Depicker A.. T‐DNA integration patterns in co-transformed plant cells suggest that T‐DNA repeats originate from co-integration of separate T-DNAs.  The Plant Journal. (1997);  11 15-29
• 16 Directive 2001/18/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 12 March 2001 on the deliberate release into the environment of genetically modified organism and repealing Council Directive 90/220/EEC.  Official Journal of the European Communities. http://europa.eu.int/eur-lex/pri/en/oj/dat/2001/l_106/l_10620010417en00010038.pdf L106 1-39
• 17 Ducreux L. J. M., Morris W. L., Hedley P. E., Shepherd T., Davies H. V., Millam S., Taylor M. A.. Metabolic engineering of high carotenoid potato tubers containing enhanced levels of b-carotene and lutein.  Journal of Experimental Botany. (2005);  65 81-89
• 18 EFSA .http://www.efsa.eu.int/science/gmo/gmo_guidance/catindex_en.html. (2004)
• 19 EU .Applications under Regulation (EC) No. 258/97 of the European Parliament and of the Council, as of April 2005. http://europa.eu.int/comm/food/food/biotechnology/novelfood/app_list_en.pdf. (2005)
• 20 FAO . ftp://ftp.fao.org/es/esn/food/guide_plants_en.pdf. (2003)
• 21 Fulton D. C., Edwards A., Pilling E., Robinson H. L., Fahy B., Seale R., Kato L., Donald A. M., Geigenberger P., Martin C., Smith A. M.. Role of granule-bound starch synthase in determination of amylopectin structure and starch granule morphology in potato.  Journal of Biological Chemistry. (2002);  277 10834-10841
• 22 Jiménez-Bermúdez S., Redondo-Nevado J., Muñoz-Blanco J., Caballero J. L., López-Aranda J. M., Valpuesta V., Pliego-Alfaro F., Quesada M. A., Mercado J. A.. Manipulation of strawberry fruit softening by antisense expression of a pectate lyase gene.  Plant Physiology. (2002);  128 751-759
• 23 Joint Research Centre .Deliberate releases and placing on the EU market of Genetically Modified Organisms (GMOs). http://gmoinfo.jrc.it/gmc_browse.asp. (2006)
• 24 Justesen U., Knuthsen P., Leth T.. Quantitative analysis of flavonols, flavones, and flavanones in fruits, vegetables and beverages by high-performance liquid chromatography with photo-diode array and mass spectrometric detection.  Journal of Chromatography A,. (1998);  799 101-110
• 25 Landry L. G., Chapple C. C., Last R. L.. Arabidopsis mutants lacking phenolic sunscreens exhibit enhanced ultraviolet-B injury and oxidative damage.  Plant Physiology. (1995);  109 1159-1166
• 11 Lashbrook C. C., Giovannoni J. J., Hall B. D., Fischer R. L., Bennett A. B.. Transgenic analysis of tomato endo-β‐1,4-glucanase gene function. Role of cel1 in floral abscission.  The Plant Journal. (1998);  13 303-310
• 26 Le Gall G., Metzdorff S. B., Pedersen J., Bennet R. N., Colquhoun I.. Primary and secondary metabolites profiling in Arabidopsis thaliana (L.) ecotype Wassilewskija with an antisense chalcone synthase transgene.  Metabolomics. (2005);  1 181-198
• 27 Mahalingam R., Gomez-Buitrago A., Eckardt N., Shah N., Guevara-Garcia A., Day P., Raina R., Fedoroff N. V.. Characterizing the stress/defense transcriptome of Arabidopsis.  Genome Biology. (2003);  4 R20
• 28 Matzke M. A., Matzke A. J. M.. How and why do plants inactivate homologous (trans)genes?.  Plant Physiology. (1995);  107 679-685
• 29 Mette M. F., Aufsatz W., van der Winden J., Matzke M. A., Matzke A. J. M.. Transcriptional silencing and promoter methylation triggered by double-stranded RNA.  The EMBO Journal. (2000);  19 5194-5201
• 30 Nordic Council .Use of cDNA microarray technology in the safety assessment of GM food plants. TemaNord 2003: 558. ISBN 92-893-0955-5. (2003)
• 31 OECD .Safety Evaluation of Foods Derived by Modern Biotechnology: Concepts and Principles. Paris; Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, OECD (1993)
• 32 Qin H., Dong Y., von Arnim A. G.. Epigenetic interactions between Arabidopsis transgenes: characterisation in light of transgene integration sites.  Plant Molecular Biology. (2003);  52 217-231
• 34 Regulation (EC) No. 1829/2003 of the European parliament and of the council of 22 September 2003 on genetically modified food and feed. 
• 35 Reymond P.. DNA microarrays and plant defence.  Plant Physiology and Metabolism. (2001);  39 313-321
• 36 Roche Molecular Biochemicals .LightCycler Operator's Manual. Version 3.5. Oktober 2000. (2000)
• 37 Rossel J. B., Wilson I. W., Pogson B. J.. Global changes in gene expression in response to high light in Arabidopsis.  Plant Physiology. (2002);  130 1109-1120
• 38 Rung J. H., Draborg H. H., Jørgensen K., Nielsen T. H.. Carbon partitioning in leaves and tubers of transgenic potato plants with reduced activity of fructose-6-phosphate,2-kinase/fructose-2,6-bisphosphatase.  Physiological Plantarum. (2004);  121 204-214
• 33 Schubert D., Lechtenberg B., Forsbach A., Gils A., Bahadur S., Schmidt R.. Silencing in Arabidopsis T‐DNA transformants: The predominant role of a gene-specific RNA sensing mechanism versus position effects.  Plant Cell. (2004);  16 2561-2572
• 39 Sessions A., Burke E., Presting G., Aux G., McElver J., Patton D., Dietrich B., Ho P., Bacwaden J., Ko C., Clarke J. D., Cotton D., Bullis D., Snell J., Miguel T., Hutchison D., Kimmerly B., Mitzel T., Katagiri F., Glazebrook J., Law M., Goff S. A.. A high-throughput Arabidopsis reverse genetics system.  Plant Cell. (2002);  14 2985-2994
• 40 Staswick P. E., Su W., Howell S. H.. Methyl jasmonate inhibition of root growth and induction of a leaf protein are decreased in an Arabidopsis thaliana mutant.  Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA. (1992);  89 6837-6840
• 41 van den Berg H., Faulks R., Granado H. F., Hirschberg J., Olmedilla B., Sandmann G., Southon S., Stahl W.. The potential for the improvement of carotenoid levels in foods and the likely systemic effects.  Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture. (2000);  80 880-912
• 42 Wang H., Provan G. J., Helliwell K.. Tea flavonoids: their function, utilisation and analysis.  Trends in Food Science and Technology. (2000);  11 152-160
• 43 WHO .Biotechnology and Food Safety. Report of a Joint FAO/WHO Expert Consultation on Biotechnology and Food Safety. Rome; (1996)
• 44 WHO .Safety Aspects of Genetically Modified Foods of Plant Origin. Report of a Joint FAO/WHO Expert Consultation on Foods Derived from Biotechnology. Geneva; WHO (2000)

Editor: M. Koornneef