The Clinical Characteristics of Tinnitus in Patients with Vestibular Schwannoma

ABSTRACT

Objectives: To review the symptoms, signs, and clinical findings in a large series of patients diagnosed with unilateral sporadic vestibular schwannoma (VS) to describe the clinical characteristics of tinnitus in this population. Further, to ascertain which of the proposed mechanisms of tinnitus generation in VS was supported. Design: Retrospective case note and database review. Setting: Tertiary university teaching hospital departments of audiology and neuro-otology. Participants: Nine hundred forty-one patients with unilateral sporadic VS, diagnosed during the period 1986 to 2002. Twenty-three additional patients were excluded due to missing clinical data. Main outcome measures: The presence or absence of tinnitus, and its rated subjective severity were analyzed in conjunction with data regarding patient demographics, symptoms, signs, and diagnostic audiovestibular test findings. Results: No statistical association at the 5% level was found between tinnitus presence/absence and patient age, gender, 2- to 4-kHz audiometric thresholds, ipsilateral auditory brainstem response abnormality, length of history, tumor side, nor caloric test abnormality. Statistically significant associations were found between tinnitus presence/absence and tumor size (p = 0.012) and type of hearing loss (progressive, sudden, fluctuant, nil) with a tendency for patients without hearing loss to be less likely to experience tinnitus. Statistically significant associations were identified between classification of tinnitus severity and age at diagnosis (p < 0.001) (greater age being associated with greater tinnitus severity), abnormal findings on caloric testing (p = 0.01) (abnormal calorics being associated with greater tinnitus severity), and tinnitus as a principal presenting symptom (p < 0.001) (this being associated with greater tinnitus severity). Conclusions: The analysis does not identify any single one of the proposed mechanisms for tinnitus as being the obvious culprit. In fact, even in a homogeneous group of patients such as this, there is evidence of multiple mechanisms that are not mutually exclusive. The association between increased tinnitus severity in older patients, patients with canal pareses on caloric testing, and with tinnitus as a principal presenting symptom should be borne in mind by the clinician.

KEYWORDS

Vestibular schwannoma - tinnitus - mechanisms

REFERENCES

• 1 Moffat D A, Baguley D M, Beynon G J, Da Cruz M. Clinical acumen and vestibular schwannoma.  Am J Otol. 1998;  19 82-87
• 2 Moller A R. Similarities between chronic pain and tinnitus.  Am J Otol. 1997;  18 577-585
• 3 Moller A R. Pathophysiology of tinnitus.  Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol. 1984;  93 39-44
• 4 Eggermont J J. On the pathophysiology of tinnitus: a review and peripheral model.  Hear Res. 1990;  48 111-124
• 5 Levine R A, Kiang NYS. A conversation about tinnitus. In: Vernon JA, Moller AR Mechanisms of Tinnitus. London, UK; Allyn and Bacon 1995: 149-160
• 6 O'Connor A F, France M W, Morrison A W. Perilymph total protein levels associated with cerebellopontine angle lesion.  Am J Otol. 1981;  2 193-195
• 7 Schuknecht H F. Pathology of the Ear. 2nd ed. Philadelphia, PA; Lea and Febiger 1993
• 8 Jahnke K, Neuman T A. The fine structure of vestibular end organs in acoustic neuroma patients. In: Tos M, Thomsen J Acoustic Neuroma. Amsterdam, The Netherlands; Kugler 1992: 203-207
• 9 Sahley T L, Nodar R H, Musiek F E. Efferent Auditory System: Structure and Function. San Diego, CA; Singular 1997
• 10 Salvi R J, Lockwood A H, Burkard R. Neural plasticity and tinnitus. In: Tyler RS Tinnitus Handbook. San Diego, CA; Singular 2000: 123-148
• 11 Sunderland S. Nerve Injuries and Their Repair: A Critical Appraisal. Edinburgh, UK; Churchill Livingstone 1991
• 12 Prasher D K, Tun T, Brookes G B, Luxon L M. Mechanisms of hearing loss in acoustic neuroma: an otoacoustic emission study.  Acta Otolaryngol. 1995;  115 375-381
• 13 Quaranta A, Salluststio V, Scaringi L. Cochlear function in ears with vestibular schwannomas. In: Sanna M, Taibah A, Russo A, Mancini F Acoustic Neurinoma and Other CPA Tumors. Bologna, Italy; Monduzzi 1999: 43-50
• 14 Ferguson M A, O'Donoghue G M, Owen V. Contralateral suppression of transient evoked otoacoustic emissions in patients with cerebello-pontine angle tumor.  Ear Hear. 2001;  22 173-181
• 15 Moffat D A, Hardy D G, Baguley D M. Strategy and benefits of acoustic neuroma searching.  J Laryngol Otol. 1989;  103 51-59
• 16 Telischi F F, Roth J, Stagner B B, Lonsbury-Martin B L, Balkany T J. Patterns of evoked otoacoustic emissions associated with acoustic neuromas.  Laryngoscope. 1995;  105 675-682
• 17 Ferber-Viart C, Colleaux B, Laoust L, Dubreuil C, Duclaux R. Is the presence of transient evoked otoacoustic emissions in ears with acoustic neuroma significant?.  Laryngoscope. 1998;  108 605-609
• 18 Bonfils P, Uziel A. Evoked otoacoustic emissions in patients with acoustic neuromas.  Am J Otol. 1988;  9 412-417
• 19 Maurer J, Hinni M, Beck A, Mann W. Effects of contralateral white noise stimulation on transitory evoked otoacoustic emissions in patients with acoustic neuroma.  Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 1995;  112 369-374
• 20 Baguley D M, Axon P, Moffat D A, Winter I M. The effect of vestibular nerve section upon tinnitus.  Clin Otolaryngol. 2002;  27 219-226
• 21 Robertson D, Irvine DRF. Plasticity of frequency organization in auditory cortex of guinea pigs with partial unilateral deafness.  J Comp Neurol. 1989;  282 456-480
• 22 Rajan R, Irvine DRF, Wise L Z, Heil P. Effect of unilateral partial cochlear lesions in adult cats on the representation of lesioned and unlesioned cochleas in primary auditory cortex.  J Comp Neurol. 1993;  338 17-49
• 23 Harrison R V, Nagasawa A, Smith D W, Stanton S, Mount R J. Reorganisation of auditory cortex after neonatal high frequency cochlear hearing loss.  Hear Res. 1991;  54 11-19
• 24 Dietrich V, Nieschalk M, Stoll W, Rajan R, Pantev C. Cortical reorganisation in patients with high frequency cochlear hearing loss.  Hear Res. 2001;  158 95-101
• 25 Thai-Van H, Micheyl C, Moore BCJ, Collet L. Enhanced frequency discrimination near the hearing loss cut-off: a consequence of central auditory plasticity induced by cochlear damage?.  Brain. 2003;  126 2235-2245
• 26 Salvi R J, Wang J, Powers N L. Plasticity and reorganisation in the auditory brainstem: implications for tinnitus. In: Reich GE, Vernon JE Proceedings of the Fifth International Tinnitus Seminar 1995. Portland, OR; American Tinnitus Association 1996: 457-466
• 27 Muhlnickel W, Elbert T, Taub E, Flor H. Reorganisation of auditory cortex in tinnitus.  Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 1998;  95 10340-10343
• 28 Norena A, Micheyl C, Chery-Croze S, Collet L. Psychoacoustic characterization of the tinnitus spectrum: implications for the underlying mechanisms of tinnitus.  Audiol Neurootol. 2002;  7 358-369
• 29 Wilson D F, Talbot M, Mills L. A critical appraisal of the role of auditory brain stem response and magnetic resonance imaging in acoustic neuroma diagnosis.  Am J Otol. 1997;  18 673-681
• 30 British Society of Audiology . Recommended procedure for pure-tone audiometry using a manually operated instrument.  Br J Audiol. 1981;  15 213-216
• 31 British Society of Audiology . Recommended procedure for pure-tone bone-conduction audiometry without masking using a manually operated instrument.  Br J Audiol. 1985;  19 281-282
• 32 British Society of Audiology . Caloric test protocol.  Br J Audiol. 1999;  33 179-184
• 33 Hall J W. Handbook of Auditory Evoked Responses. Boston, MA; Allyn and Bacon 1992
• 34 Klockhoff I, Lindblom U. Meniere's disease and hydrochlorothiazide (Dichlotride)-a critical analysis of symptoms and therapeutic effects.  Acta Otolaryngol. 1967;  63 347-365
• 35 Baguley D M, Moffat D A, Hardy D G. What is the effect of translabyrinthine acoustic schwannoma removal upon tinnitus?.  J Laryngol Otol. 1992;  106 329-331
• 36 Nodar R H, Kinney S E. The contralateral effects of large tumours on brainstem auditory evoked potentials.  Laryngoscope. 1980;  90 1762-1768
• 37 Musiek F E, Kibbe K. Auditory brainstem response wave IV-V abnormalities from the ear opposite large cerebellopontine angle lesions.  Am J Otol. 1986;  7 253-257
• 38 Andersson G. Tinnitus loudness matchings in relation to annoyance and grading of severity.  Auris Nasus Larynx. 2003;  30 129-133
• 39 Cacace A T. Expanding the biological basis of tinnitus: cross-modal origins and the role of neuroplasticity.  Hear Res. 2003;  175 112-132
• 40 Erlandsson S I, Hallberg L RM, Axelsson A. Psychological and audiological correlates of perceived tinnitus severity.  Audiology. 1992;  31 168-179
• 41 Davis A C, Rafaie E A. Epidemiology of tinnitus. In: Tyler RS Tinnitus Handbook. San Diego, CA; Singular 2000: 1-24