Reinstatement of Chiastocaulon Carl (Plagiochilaceae), Based on Evidence from Nuclear Ribosomal ITS and Chloroplast Gene rps4 Sequences

Abstract

Morphological approaches have led to controversial opinions regarding the systematic position of the Asian Jungermannia dendroides Nees within the family Plagiochilaceae. In recent times, the taxon was treated both as genus Chiastocaulon Carl, as a member of Plagiochila sect. Dendroideae Gottsche, Lindenb. and Nees, and as a representative of Plagiochila subgen. Chiastocaulon (Carl) Inoue. Sequences of the chloroplast-encoded rps4 gene and the internal transcribed spacers of nuclear ribosomal DNA of 28 representatives of the Plagiochilaceae and Herbertus subdentatus (Herbertaceae, outgroup) were obtained to test the different hypotheses. Maximum likelihood analyses were performed, both on the separate and combined data sets, and in all cases resulted in a single optimal topology. The different phylogenies were congruent, but the analyses of the combined data set led to an overall more significant bootstrap support. Jungermannia dendroides was placed in a moderately supported clade with Pedinophyllum interruptum and Plagiochilion mayebarae, sister to the well supported Plagiochila clade. The topology justifies the recognition of Jungermannia dendroides as genus Chiastocaulon. Plagiochila frondescens (Nees) Lindenb., P. fruticosa Mitt. and P. pulcherrima Horik., placed alongside Chiastocaulon/Plagiochila dendroides by some authors, form a robust clade within Plagiochila (Dumort.) Dumort., assignable to P. sect. Fruticosae Inoue. The three species share the dendroid habit and alternating foliation with Chiastocaulon dendroides but lack well developed ventral intercalary branches. 11 sectional clades with robust bootstrap support were identified within the Plagiochila lineage. Many morphological characters of monophyletic lineages within the Plagiochilaceae appeared homoplastic, indicating that a natural subdivision of the family is only possible by the integration of molecular data. The molecular topologies justify a hierarchical subdivision of Plagiochila at some point in the future; however, well supported sectional groups of the molecular trees will presumably lack morphological autapomorphisms.

Key words

Plagiochila - Chiastocaulon - molecular phylogeny - rps4 - ITS

References

• 1 Arnheim N.. Concerted evolution of multigene families. Nei, M. and Koehn, R. K., eds. Evolution of Genes and Proteins. Sunderland; Sinauer Assoc. (1983): 38-61
• 2 Baldwin B. G., Sanderson M. J., Porter J. M., Wojciechowski M. F., Campbell C. S., Donoghue M. J.. The ITS region of nuclear ribosomal DNA: a valuable source of angiosperm phylogeny.  Annals of the Missouri Botanical Garden. (1995);  82 247-277
• 3 Carl H.. Morphologische Studien an Chiastocaulon Carl, einer neuen Lebermoosgattung.  Flora. (1931);  126 45-60
• 4 Cox C. J., Hedderson T. A. J.. Phylogenetic relationships within the moss family Bryaceae based on chloroplast DNA evidence.  Journal of Bryology. (2003);  25 31-40
• 5 Dugas M.. Contribution a l'étude du genre “Plagiochila” Dum.  Annales des Sciences Naturelles, Botanique, Série 10. (1928);  11 1-199
• 6 Farris J. S., Källersjö M., Kluge A. G., Bult C.. Testing significance of incongruence.  Cladistics. (1995);  10 315-319
• 7 Felsenstein J.. Confidence limits on phylogenies: an approach using the bootstrap.  Evolution. (1985);  39 783-791
• 8 Goffinet B., Bayer R. J., Vitt D. H.. Circumscription and phylogeny of the Orthotrichales (Bryopsida) inferred from rbcL sequence analyses.  American Journal of Botany. (1998);  85 1324-1337
• 9 Gottsche C. M., Lindenberg J. B. W., Nees ab Esenbeck C. G.. Synopsis Hepaticarum. Hamburg; Meissner (1844 - 1847): 834
• 10 Grolle R., Heinrichs J.. Eocene Plagiochila groehnii sp. nov. - the first representative of Plagiochilaceae in Baltic amber.  Cryptogamie, Bryologie. (2003);  24 289-293
• 11 Groth H., Helms G., Heinrichs J.. The systematic status of Plagiochila sects. Bidentes Carl and Caducilobae Inoue (Hepaticae) inferred from nrDNA ITS sequences.  Taxon. (2002);  51 675-684
• 12 Groth H., Lindner M., Wilson R., Hartmann F. A., Schmull M., Gradstein S. R., Heinrichs J.. Biogeography of Plagiochila (Hepaticae): natural species groups span several floristic kingdoms.  Journal of Biogeography. (2003);  30 965-978
• 13 Hall T. A.. BioEdit: a user-friendly biological sequence alignment editor and analysis program for Windows 95/98/NT.  Nucleic Acids Symposia Series. (1999);  41 95-98
• 14 Hattori S.. Five new genera of Hepaticae.  Biosphaera. (1947);  1 3-7
• 15 Heinrichs J.. A taxonomic revision of Plagiochila sect. Hylacoetes, sect. Adiantoideae and sect. Fuscoluteae in the Neotropics with a preliminary subdivision of neotropical Plagiochilaceae into nine lineages.  Bryophytorum Bibiliotheca. (2002);  58 1-184 Append. 1-5
• 16 Heinrichs J., Anton H., Gradstein S. R., Mues R.. Systematics of Plagiochila sect. Glaucescentes Carl (Hepaticae) from tropical America: a morphological and chemotaxonomical approach.  Plant Systematics and Evolution. (2000 a);  220 115-138
• 17 Heinrichs J., Anton H., Gradstein S. R., Mues R., Holz I.. Surface wax, a new taxonomic feature in Plagiochilaceae.  Plant Systematics and Evolution. (2000 b);  225 225-233
• 18 Heinrichs J., Gradstein S. R., Groth H., Lindner M.. Plagiochila cucullifolia var. anomala var. nov. from Ecuador, with notes on discordant molecular and morphological variation in Plagiochila. .  Plant Systematics and Evolution. (2003);  242 205-216
• 19 Heinrichs J., Grolle R., Drehwald U.. The conspecificity of Plagiochila killarniensis Pearson and P. bifaria (Sw.) Lindenb.  Journal of Bryology. (1998);  20 495-497
• 20 Heinrichs J., Groth H., Holz I., Rycroft D. S., Renker C., Pröschold T.. The systematic position of Plagiochila moritziana, P. trichostoma, and P. deflexa based on ITS sequence variation of nuclear ribosomal DNA, morphology, and lipophilic secondary metabolites.  The Bryologist. (2002 a);  105 189-203
• 21 Heinrichs J., Pröschold T., Renker C., Groth H., Rycroft D. S.. Plagiochila virginica A. Evans rather than P. dubia Lindenb. and Gottsche occurs in Macaronesia; placement in sect. Contiguae Carl is supported by ITS sequences of nuclear ribosomal DNA.  Plant Systematics and Evolution. (2002 b);  230 221-230
• 22 Heinrichs J., Sauer M., Grolle R.. Lectotypification and synonymy of Plagiochila sect. Vagae Lindenb. (Hepaticae).  Cryptogamie, Bryologie. (2002 c);  23 5-9
• 23 Hellwig F. H., Nolte M., Ochsmann J., Wissemann V.. Rapid isolation of total DNA from milligram plant tissue.  Haussknechtia. (1999);  7 29-34
• 24 Hillis D. M., Bull J. J.. An empirical test of bootstrapping as a method for assessing the confidence in phylogenetic analysis.  Systematic Biology. (1993);  42 182-192
• 25 Inoue H.. The family Plagiochilaceae of Japan and Formosa.  I. Journal of the Hattori Botanical Laboratory. (1958);  19 25-59
• 26 Inoue H.. The genus Plagiochilion. .  Journal of the Hattori Botanical Laboratory. (1964);  27 51-72
• 45 Inoue H.. Taxonomic miscellany on the Plagiochilaceae.  The Journal of Japanese Botany. (1967);  42 182-187
• 27 Inoue H.. The genus Plagiochila (Dum.) Dum. in southeast Asia. Tokyo; Academic Scientific Book Inc. (1984)
• 28 Jones E. W.. African Hepatics. XV. Plagiochila in tropical Africa.  Transactions of the British Bryological Society. (1962);  4 254-325
• 29 Koch M. A., Dobes C., Mitchell-Olds T.. Multiple hybrid formation in natural populations: Concerted evolution of the internal transcribed spacer of nuclear ribosomal DNA (ITS) in north American Arabis divaricarpa (Brassicaceae).  Molecular Biology and Evolution. (2003);  20 338-350
• 30 Long D. G., Möller M., Preston J.. Phylogenetic relationships of Asterella (Aytoniaceae, Marchantiopsida) inferred from chloroplast DNA sequences.  The Bryologist. (2000);  625-644
• 31 Mason-Gamer R. J., Kellog E. A.. Testing for phylogenetic conflict among molecular data sets in the tribe Triticeae (Gramineae).  Systematic Biology. (1996);  45 524-545
• 32 Posada D., Crandall K. A.. Modeltest: testing the model of DNA substitution.  Bioinformatics. (1998);  14 817-818
• 33 Renker C., Heinrichs J., Pröschold T., Groth H., Holz I.. ITS sequences of nuclear ribosomal DNA support the generic placement and the disjunct range of Plagiochila (Adelanthus) carringtonii. .  Cryptogamie, Bryologie. (2002);  23 23-29
• 34 Rycroft D. S., Cole W. J., Heinrichs J., Groth H., Renker C., Pröschold T.. Phytochemical, morphological and molecular evidence for the occurrence of the neotropical liverwort Plagiochila stricta in the Canary Islands, new to Macaronesia.  The Bryologist. (2002);  105 363-372
• 35 Shaw A. J.. Phylogeny of the Sphagnopsida based on chloroplast and nuclear DNA sequences.  The Bryologist. (2000);  103 277-306
• 36 Shaw A. J., Goffinet B.. Molecular evidence of reticulate evolution in the peatmosses (Sphagnum), including S. ehyalinum sp. nov.  The Bryologist. (2000);  103 357-374
• 37 Shaw A. J., McDaniel S. F., Werner O., Ros R. M.. New frontiers in bryology and lichenology - phylogeography and phylodemography.  The Bryologist. (2002);  105 373-383
• 38 So M. L.. On Plagiochila (Hepaticae) section Dendroideae. .  Nova Hedwigia. (2001 a);  73 229-238
• 39 So M. L.. Plagiochila (Hepaticae, Plagiochilaceae) in China.  Systematic Botany Monographs. (2001 b);  60 1-214
• 40 So M. L., Grolle R.. Checklist of Plagiochila (Hepaticae) in Asia.  Journal of the Hattori Botanical Laboratory. (2000);  88 199-243
• 41 Souza-Chies T. T., Bittar G., Nadot S., Carter L., Besin E., Lejeune B.. Phylogenetic analysis of Iridaceae with parsimony and distance methods using the plastid gene rps4.  Plant Systematics and Evolution. (1997);  204 109-123
• 42 Swofford D. L.. PAUP*, phylogenetic analysis using parsimony (*and other methods). Sunderland, MA; Sinauer Associates (2000)
• 43 Vanderpoorten A., Hedenäs L., Cox C. J., Shaw A. J.. Phylogeny and morphological evolution of the Amblystegiaceae (Bryopsida).  Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution. (2002);  23 1-21
• 46 Vanderpoorten A., Shaw A. J., Goffinet B.. Testing controversial alignments in Amblystegium and related genera (Amblystegiaceae: Bryopsida). Evidence from rDNA ITS sequences.  Systematic Botany. (2001);  26 470-479
• 44 Wissemann V.. Genetic constitution of Rosa sect. Caninae (R. canina, R. jundzillii) and sect. Gallicanae (R. gallica). .  Journal of Applied Botany. (1999);  73 191-196

Section Editor: F. Salamini