Erb and Westphal: Simultaneous Discovery of the Deep Tendon Reflexes

ABSTRACT

Although the deep tendon reflexes (DTRs) were first introduced simultaneously into the medical literature by Erb and Westphal (1875), there is some evidence that the knee jerk response was well known to laymen prior to that time. Erb wrote that while he was not calling attention to anything new, he realized the utility of the phenomenon in diagnosing certain disease states. Erb viewed the phenomenon more clearly as a true reflex arc, whereas Westphal interpreted it as a local muscle phenomenon. By 1885, the maneuver was used in Europe and across the Atlantic in America. By then, the DTRs had become one of the cardinal features of the neurological examination.

KEYWORD

Deep tendon reflexes - percussion hammer - Erb - Westphal

REFERENCES

• 1 Louis E D, Kaufmann P. Erb's explanation for the tendon reflexes: links between science and the clinic.  Arch Neurol . 1996;  53 1187-1189
• 2 Haerer A E. DeJong's The Neurological Examination.  5th ed. Philadelphia: Lippincott Raven 1992
• 3 McHenry L C. Garrison's History of Neurology.  Springfield, IL: Charles C. Thomas 1969
• 4 Clarke E, O'Malley C D. The Human Brain and Spinal Cord.  Berkeley, CA: University of California Press 1968
• 5 Viets H R. Wilhelm Heinrich Erb. In: W Haymaker, ed. The Founders of Neurology Springfield, IL: Charles C. Thomas 1953
• 6 Erb W H. Über Sehnenreflexe bei Gesunden und Rückenmarkskranken.  Archiv fur Psychiat und Nervenkrankh . 1875;  5 792-802
• 7 Westphal C O. Über einige Bewegungs-Erscheinungen an gelähmten Gliedern.  Arch fur Psych und Nervenkrankh . 1875;  5 803-834
• 8 Erb W. Handbuch der Krankheiten des Nervensystems I.  Leipzig: F.C.W. Vogel 1876
• 9 Buzzard T. On a prolonged first stage of tabes dorsalis: amaurosis, lightning, pains, recurrent herpes; not ataxia; absence of patellar tendon reflex.  Brain 1878-. 1879;  1 168-181
• 10 Atkins R. A case of right hemiplegia, hemianesthesia, and aphasia, having for its prominent anatomical lesion softening of the left lateral lobe of the cerebellum.  Brain 1878-. 1879;  1 410-417
• 11 MacCormac W. Traumatic lesion of the left hemisphere-right brachio-facial paralysis-aphasia-antiseptic treatment- recovery.  Brain 1878-. 1879;  1 256-260
• 12 Hamilton A M. The value of absent "tendon-reflex" as a diagnostic sign in locomotor ataxia, with an analysis of eight cases.  Boston Med Surg J . 1878;  99 781-788
• 13 Mills C K. Some forms of myelitis, their diagnosis from each other and from hysterical paraplegia.  Med News . 1885;  47 169-173