Task Specificity in Early Oral Motor Development

ABSTRACT

This article addresses a long-standing clinical and theoretical debate regarding the potential relationship between speech and nonspeech behaviors in the developing system. The review is motivated by the high popularity of nonspeech oral motor exercises (NSOMEs), including alimentary behaviors such as chewing, in the treatment of speech disorders in young children. The similarities and differences in the behavioral characteristics, sensory requirements, and task goals for speech and nonspeech oromotor behaviors are compared. Integrated theoretical paradigms and empirical data on the development of early oromotor behaviors are discussed. Although the efficacy of NSOMEs remains empirically untested at this time, studies of typical developmental speech physiology fail to support a theoretical framework promoting the use of NSOMEs. Well-designed empirical studies are necessary, however, to establish the efficacy of NSOMEs for specific clinical population and treatment targets.

KEYWORDS

Speech - oral-motor - nonspeech oral motor exercises (NSOMEs) - speech physiology - task specificity - motor development

REFERENCES

• 1 Maas E, Robin D A, Austermann Hula S N et al.. Principles of motor learning in treatment of motor speech disorders.  Am J Speech Lang Pathol. 2008;  17(3) 277-298
• 2 Moore C A, Ruark J L. Does speech emerge from earlier appearing oral motor behaviors?.  J Speech Hear Res. 1996;  39(5) 1034-1047
• 3 Weismer G. Philosophy of research in motor speech disorders.  Clin Linguist Phon. 2006;  20(5) 315-349
• 4 Ziegler W. Speech motor control is task-specific: evidence from dysarthria and apraxia of speech.  Aphasiology. 2003;  17 3-36
• 5 MacNeilage P F. The frame/content theory of evolution of speech production.  Behav Brain Sci. 1998;  21(4) 499-546
• 6 Ballard K J, Robin D A, Folkins J W. An integrative model of speech motor control: a response to Ziegler.  Aphasiology. 2003;  17 37-48
• 7 de Vries J L, Visser G H, Prechtl H F. The emergence of fetal behaviour. I. Qualitative aspects.  Early Hum Dev. 2008;  7(4) 301-322
• 8 Green J R, Wilson E M. Spontaneous facial motility in infancy: a 3D kinematic analysis.  Dev Psychobiol. 2006;  48(1) 16-28
• 9 Gibson E J. Exploratory behavior in the development of perceiving, acting, and the acquiring of knowledge.  Annu Rev Psychol. 1988;  39 1-41
• 10 Chen X, Striano T, Rakoczy H. Auditory-oral matching behavior in newborns.  Dev Sci. 2004;  7(1) 42-47
• 11 Meltzoff A N, Moore M K. Newborn infants imitate adult facial gestures.  Child Dev. 1983;  54 702-709
• 12 Rochat P, Morgan R. The function and determinants of early self-exploration. In: Rochat P The Self in Infancy: Theory and Research. Amsterdam, The Netherlands; Elsevier Science B.V. 1995
• 13 Thelen E. Developmental origins of motor coordination: Leg movements in human infants.  Dev Psychobiol. 1985;  18 1-22
• 14 Bernstein N A. The Co-ordination and Regulation of Movements. Oxford, United Kingdom; Pergamon 1967
• 15 Turvey M T. Coordination.  Am Psychol. 1990;  45 938-953
• 16 Tremblay S, Houle G, Ostry D J. Specificity of speech motor learning.  J Neurosci. 2008;  28(10) 2426-2434
• 17 Bunton K. Speech versus nonspeech: different tasks, different neural organization.  Semin Speech Lang. 2008;  29 267-275
• 18 Finan D S, Barlow S M. The actifier: a device for neurophysiological studies of orofacial control in human infants.  J Speech Hear Res. 1996;  39(4) 833-838
• 19 Woolbridge M W. The ‘anatomy’ of infant sucking.  Midwifery. 1986;  2 164-171
• 20 Steeve R, Moore C, Green J, Reilly K, McMurtrey J. Babbling, chewing and sucking: oromandibular coordination at 9 months.  J Speech Hear Res. 2008;  , Epub ahead of print
• 21 Wilson E M, Green J R. Coordinative organization of lingual propulsion during the normal adult swallow.  Dysphagia. 2006;  21(4) 226-236
• 22 Muller E M, Milenkovic P H, MacLeod G E. Perioral tissue mechanics during speech production. In: Eisenfeld J, Delisi C Mathematics and Computers in Biomedical Applications. Amsterdam, The Netherlands; Elsevier Science 1984
• 23 Langmore S E, Lehman M E. Physiologic deficits in the orofacial system underlying dysarthria in amyotrophic lateral sclerosis.  J Speech Hear Res. 1994;  37(1) 28-37
• 24 Green J R, Moore C A, Ruark J L, Rodda P R, Morvee W T, VanWitzenburg M J. Development of chewing in children from 12 to 48 months: longitudinal study of EMG patterns.  J Neurophysiol. 1997;  77(5) 2704-2716
• 25 Arvedson J C, Lefton-Greif M A. Anatomy, physiology, and development of feeding.  Semin Speech Lang. 1996;  17(4) 261-268
• 26 Pinder G L, Faherty A S. Issues in pediatric feeding and swallowing. In: Caruso AJ, Strand EA Clinical Management of Motor Speech Disorders in Children. New York, NY; Thieme 1999: 281-318
• 27 Meier R P, McGarvin L, Zakia R A, Willerman R. Silent mandibular oscillations in vocal babbling.  Phonetica. 1997;  54(3–4) 153-171
• 28 Wilson E M. Kinematic Description of Chewing Development [dissertation]. Madison, Wisconsin; University of Wisconsin-Madison 2005
• 29 Green J R, Moore C A, Higashikawa M, Steeve R W. The physiologic development of speech motor control: lip and jaw coordination.  J Speech Lang Hear Res. 2000;  43 239-255
• 30 Cheng H Y, Murdoch B E, Goosee J V, Scott D. Physiologic development of tongue–jaw coordination from childhood to adulthood.  J Speech Lang Hear Res. 2007;  50 352-360
• 31 Abbs J H, Gracco V L, Cole K J. Control of multimovement coordination: sensorimotor mechanisms in speech motor programming.  J Mot Behav. 1984;  16 195-231
• 32 Fairbanks G. Systematic research in experimental phonetics: a theory of the speech mechanism as a servosystem.  J Speech Dis. 1954;  19 133-139
• 33 Guenther F H. Cortical interactions underlying the production of speech.  J Commun Disord. 2006;  39 350-365
• 34 Nasir S M, Ostry D. Somatosensory precision in speech production.  Curr Biol. 2006;  16 1918-1923
• 35 Finan D S, Barlow S M. Intrinsic dynamics and mechanosensory modulation of non-nutritive sucking in human infants.  Early Hum Dev. 1998;  52(2) 181-197
• 36 Dellow P G, Lund J P. Evidence for central timing of rhythmical mastication.  J Physiol. 1971;  215 1-13
• 37 Lund J P. Mastication and its control by the brain stem.  Crit Rev Oral Biol Med. 1991;  2(1) 33-64
• 38 Thexton A J. Mastication and swallowing: an overview.  Br Dent J. 1992;  173 197-206
• 39 Guenther F H. Speech sound acquisition, coarticulation, and rate effects in a neural network model of speech production.  Psychol Rev. 1995;  102(3) 594-621
• 40 Ménard L, Schwartz J-L, Boë L-J. The role of vocal tract morphology in speech development: perceptual targets and sensori-motor maps for French synthesized vowels from birth to adulthood.  J Speech Lang Hear Res. 2004;  47 1059-1080
• 41 Vihman M M. Variable paths to early word production.  J Phonetics. 1993;  21 61-82
• 42 Westerman G, Miranda E R. A new model of sensorimotor coupling in the development of speech.  Brain Lang. 2004;  89 393-400
• 43 Kuhl P K, Meltzoff A N. The bimodal perception of speech in infancy.  Science. 1982;  218(4577) 1138-1141
• 44 Kuhl P K, Meltzoff A N. The intermodal representation of speech in infants.  Infant Behav Dev. 1984;  7 361-381
• 45 Darley F L, Aronson A E, Brown J R. Motor Speech Disorders. Philadelphia, PA; WB Saunders 1975
• 46 Lund J P, Appenteng K, Seguin J J. Analogies and common features in the speech and masticatory control systems. In: Grillner S, Lindblom P, Lubker J, Persson A Speech Motor Control. New York, NY; Pergamon 1982: 231-245
• 47 Jacob F. Evolution and tinkering.  Science. 1977;  196 1161-1166
• 48 Grillner S. Possible analogies in the control of innate motor acts and the production of sound in speech. In: Grillner S, Lindblom P, Lubker J, Persson A Speech Motor Control. New York, NY; Pergamon 1981: 217-230
• 49 Lund J P, Kolta A. Brainstem circuits that control mastication: do they have anything to say during speech?.  J Commun Disord. 2006;  39(5) 381-390
• 50 Ruark J L, Moore C A. Coordination of lip muscle activity by 2-year-old children during speech and nonspeech tasks.  J Speech Lang Hear Res. 1997;  40(6) 1373-1385
• 51 Moore C A, Smith A, Ringel R L. Task-specific organization of activity in human jaw muscles.  J Speech Hear Res. 1988;  31 670-680
• 52 Moore C A. Symmetry of mandibular muscle activity as an index of coordinative strategy.  J Speech Hear Res. 1993;  36(6) 1145-1157
• 53 Green J R, Moore C A, Reilly K J. Methodological issues in studies of early articulatory development: a response to Dworkin, et al.  J Speech Lang Hear Res. 2003;  46 1020-1021
• 54 Lof G L, Watson M M. A nationwide survey of nonspeech oral motor exercise use: implications for evidence-based practice.  Lang Speech Hear Serv Sch. 2008;  39 392-407
• 55 Fawcus B. Oropharyngeal function in relation to speech.  Dev Med Child Neurol. 1969;  11(5) 556-560