Analysis of Differential Expression of Barley ESTs during Cold Acclimatization Using Microarray Technology

Abstract

Genomics adds a new dimension to genetic analysis, shifting the focus from the study of a single gene to the whole genome. We have successfully applied the genomics approach based on microarray to the study of genes involved in barley responses to cold stress. About 900 EST clones from barley were obtained from a cDNA library of cold acclimatized leaves of cv. Nure and arrayed, and gene expression analysis done on cold acclimatized vs. control plants. The system allowed for reliable detection of differences in mRNA expression levels, and was confirmed by the finding that numerous previously reported cold-related genes were differentially expressed in treated and untreated plants when evaluated in our arrays. The expression profiles of a sample of genes analysed by the array were confirmed by quantitative RT-PCR.

Previously, identification of novel plant genes was achieved considering a few genes at a time; now many genes can be found as up- or down-regulated based on a one step procedure. Many of the genes we found to be up- or down-regulated do not have an assigned function. This includes 15 of the 78 up-regulated and 8 of the 45 down-regulated clones. Our results add new genes to the group of cold-regulated genes and provide the opportunity to better understand the complex mechanism of stress tolerance.

Key words

Barley - cold acclimatization - functional genomics - gene expression - microarrays - real time RT-PCR

References

• 01 Adams,  M. D.,, Kerlavage,  A. R.,, Fields,  C.,, and Venter,  J. C.. (1993);  3400 new expressed gene sequence tags identify diversity of transcripts in human brain.  Nature Genetics. 4 256-267
• 02 Aharoni,  A.,, Keizer,  L. C. P.,, Bouwmeester,  H. J.,, Sun,  Z.,, Alvarez-Huerta,  M.,, Verhoeven,  H. A.,, Blaas,  J.,, van Houwelingen,  A. M. M. L.,, De Vos,  R. C. H.,, van der Voet,  H.,, Jansen,  R. C.,, Guis,  M.,, Mol,  J.,, Davis,  R. W.,, Schena,  M.,, van Tunen,  A. J.,, and O'Connell,  A. P.. (2000);  Identification of the SAAT gene involved in strawberry flavor biogenesis by use of DNA microarray.  The Plant Cell. 12 647-661
• 03 Arimura,  G.,, Tashiro,  K.,, Kuhara,  S.,, Nishioka,  T.,, Ozawa,  R.,, and Takabayashi,  J.. (2000);  Gene responses in bean leaves induced by herbivory and by herbivore-induced volatiles.  Biochemical and Biophysical Research Communications. 277 305-310
• 04 Baldi,  P.,, Grossi,  M.,, Pecchioni,  N.,, Valè,  G.,, and Cattivelli,  L.. (1999);  High expression level of a gene coding for a chloroplastic amino acid selective channel protein is correlated to cold acclimation in cereals.   Plant Molecular Biology. 41 233-243
• 05 Baldi,  P.,, Valè,  G.,, Mazzucotelli,  E.,, Govoni,  C.,, Faccioli,  P.,, Stanca,  A. M.,, and Cattivelli,  L.. (2001);  The transcripts of several components of the protein synthesis machinery are cold-regulated in a chloroplast-dependent manner in barley and wheat.  J. Plant Physiology. 158 1541-1546
• 06 Bouchez,  D., and Höfte,  H.. (1998);  Functional genomics in plants.  Plant Physiology. 118 725-732
• 07 Castiglioni,  P.,, Pozzi,  C.,, Heun,  M.,, Terzi,  V.,, Müller,  K. J.,, Rohde,  W.,, and Salamini,  F.. (1998);  An AFLP-based procedure for the efficient mapping of mutations and DNA probes in barley.  Genetics. 149 2039-2056
• 08 Cattivelli,  L.,, Baldi,  P.,, Crosatti,  C.,, Di Fonzo,  N.,, Faccioli,  P.,, Grossi,  M.,, Mastrangelo,  A. M.,, Pecchioni,  N.,, and Stanca,  A. M.. (2002);  Chromosome regions and stress-related sequences involved in resistance to abiotic stress in Triticeae. .  Plant Molecular Biology. 48 649-665
• 09 Cheung,  V. G.,, Morley,  M.,, Aguillar,  F.,, Massimi,  A.,, Kucherlapati,  R.,, and Childs,  G.. (1999);  Making and reading microarrays.  Nature Genetics. 21 15-19
• 10 Cooke,  R.,, Mache,  R.,, and Hofte,  H.. (1996) EST and genomic sequencing projects. Plant genes isolation: principles and practice. Foster, G. D. and Twell D., eds. New York; John Wiley and Sons pp. 401-419
• 11 Crosatti,  C.,, Polverino de Laureto,  P.,, Bassi,  R.,, and Cattivelli,  L.. (1999);  The interaction between cold and light controls the expression of the cold-regulated barley gene cor14b and the accumulation of the corresponding protein.  Plant Physiology. 119 671-680
• 12 Eisen,  M. B., and Brown,  P.. (1999);  DNA arrays for analysis of gene expression.  Methods in Enzymology. 303 179-205
• 13 Ewing,  R. M.,, Kahla,  A. B.,, Poirot,  O.,, Lopez,  F.,, Audic,  S.,, and Claverie,  J. M.. (1999);  Large-scale statistical analyses of rice ESTs reveal correlated patterns of gene expression.  Genome Research. 9 950-959
• 14 Faccioli,  P.,, Pecchioni,  N.,, Cattivelli,  L.,, Stanca,  A. M.,, and Terzi,  V.. (2001);  Expressed sequence tags from cold-acclimatized barley can identify novel plant genes.  Plant Breeding. 120 497-502
• 15 Gerhold,  D.,, Rushmore,  T.,, and Caskey,  C. T.. (1999);  DNA chips: promising toys have become powerful tools.  TIBS. 24 168-173
• 16 Girke,  T.,, Todd,  J.,, Ruuska,  S.,, White,  J.,, Benning,  C.,, and Ohlrogge,  J.. (2000);  Microarray analysis of developing Arabidopsis seeds.  Plant Physiology. 124 1570-1581
• 17 Grossi,  M.,, Giorni,  E.,, Rizza,  F.,, Stanca,  A. M.,, and Cattivelli,  L.. (1998);  Wild and cultivated barleys show differences in the expression pattern of a cold-regulated gene family under different light and temperature conditions.  Plant Molecular Biology. 38 1061-1069
• 18 Król,  M.,, Ivanov,  A. G.,, Jansson,  S.,, Kloppstech,  K.,, and Huner,  N. P. A.. (1999);  Greening under high light or cold temperature affects the level of xanthophyll-cycle pigments, early light-inducible proteins and light-harvesting polypeptides in wild type barley and the Chlorina ƒ2 mutant.  Plant Physiology. 120 193-203
• 19 Kurth,  J.,, Varotto,  C.,, Pesaresi,  P.,, Biehl,  A.,, Richly,  E.,, Salamini,  F.,, and Leister,  D.. (2002);  Gene-sequence-tag expression analyses of 1,800 genes related to chloroplast functions.  Planta. 215 101-109
• 20 Pearce,  R. S.,, Dunn,  M. A.,, Rixon,  J.,, Harrison,  P.,, and Hughes,  M. A.. (1996);  Expression of cold-inducible genes and frost hardiness in the crown meristem of young barley (Hordeum vulgare L. cv. Igri) plants grown in different environments.  Plant Cell Environment. 19 275-290
• 21 Pfaffl,  M. W., and Hageleit,  M.. (2001);  Validities of mRNA quantification using recombinant RNA and recombinant DNA external calibration curves in Real-Time RT-PCR.  Biotechnology Letters. 23 275-282
• 22 Quackenbush,  J.,, Cho,  J.,, Lee,  D.,, Liang,  F.,, Holt,  I.,, Karamycheva,  S.,, Parvizi,  B.,, Pertea,  G.,, Sultana,  R.,, and White,  J.. (2001);  The TIGR Gene Indices: analysis of gene transcript sequences in highly sampled eukaryotic species.  Nucleic Acids Research. 29 (1) 159-164
• 23 Rajeevan,  M. S.,, Vernon,  S. D.,, Taysavang,  N.,, and Unger,  E. R.. (2001);  Validation of array-based gene expression profiles by Real-Time (kinetic) RT-PCR.  Journal of Molecular Diagnostics. 3 (1) 26-31
• 24 Sambrook,  J.,, Fritch,  E. F.,, and Maniatis,  T.. (1989) Molecular cloning. A laboratory manual, 2nd edn.  Cold Spring Harbor; Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press
• 25 Schaffer,  R.,, Landgraf,  J.,, Accerbi,  M.,, Simon,  V.,, Larson,  M.,, and Wisman,  E.. (2001);  Microarray analysis of diurnal and circadian-regulated genes in Arabidopsis.  The Plant Cell. 13 113-123
• 26 Schena,  M.,, Shalon,  D.,, Davis,  R. W.,, and Brown,  P. O.. (1995);  Quantitative monitoring of gene expression patterns with a complementary DNA microarray.  Science. 270 467-470
• 27 Schenk,  P. M.,, Kazan,  K.,, Wilson,  I.,, Anderson,  J. P.,, Richmond,  T.,, Somerville,  S. C.,, and Manners,  J. M.. (2000);  Coordinated plant defence responses in Arabidopsis revealed by microarray analysis.  PNAS. 97 11655-11660
• 28 Schmittgen,  T. D.,, Zakrajsek,  B. A.,, Mills,  A. G.,, Gorn,  V.,, Singer,  M. J.,, and Reed,  M. W.. (2000);  Quantitative Reverse Transcription-Polymerase Chain Reaction to study mRNA decay: comparison of endpoint and real-time methods.  Analytical Biochemistry. 285 194-204
• 29 Tjus,  S. E.,, Møller,  B. L.,, and Scheller,  H. V.. (1998);  Photosystem I is an early target of photo inhibition in barley illuminated at chilling temperatures.  Plant Physiology. 116 755-764
• 30 Wu,  X.,, Bayle,  J. H.,, Olson,  D.,, and Levine,  A. J.. (1993);  The p53-mdm-2 autoregulatory feedback loop.  Genes & Development. 7 1126-1132
• 31 Wurmbach,  E.,, Yuen,  T.,, Ebersole,  B. J.,, and Sealfon,  S. C.. (2001);  Gonadotropin releasing hormone receptor-coupled gene network organization.  Journal of Biological Chemistry. 276 47195-47201

Section Editor: F. Salamini