The Impact of Herbivory and Competition on Flowering and Survival during Saltmarsh Succession

Abstract:

For succession, the establishment and turnover of plants, in terms of generative spreading and renewal, is of crucial importance. Especially the success of seedling establishment into the existing vegetation might be of prime importance for the further development of plant species composition. Flowering, on the other hand, is the necessary first step towards generative output and later seed set. In a chronosequential gradient of a saltmarsh succession, we investigated the performance of transplants of three common species under different conditions: Artemisia maritima, Atriplex portulacoides and Plantago maritima were transplanted as seedlings and mature plants into plots in early-, mid-, and late-successional stages (15, 30 and 40 years) on the Dutch island of Schiermonnikoog. Natural herbivory (by hares and geese) and neighbourhood competition were excluded in a factorial design. Flowering and survival rates of the three species were generally greatly reduced under natural conditions, compared to competition- and herbivory-free plots. The survival rates of Artemisia maritima and Plantago maritima reflect their position as early-successional species: early in succession, both show their highest survival and abundance. For late-dominant Atriplex portulacoides a different explanation has to be invoked for the medium-high survival and low abundance: probably winter grazing by hares and the importance of a high nitrogen supply rate, rather than flowering and survival, determine its low abundance in the early and mid-phase of this saltmarsh succession. Some long-term impacts of herbivores affecting flowering and survival are discussed.

Key words:

Artemisia maritima - Atriplex portulacoides - Plantago maritima - saltmarsh - Schiermonnikoog - succession

References

• 01 Aarssen,  L. W., and Epp,  G. A.. (1990);  Neighbour manipulations in natural vegetation: a review.  Journal of Vegetation Science. 1 13-30
• 02 Bakker,  J. P., and De Vries,  Y.. (1992);  Germination and early establishment of lower salt-marsh species in grazed and mown salt marsh.  Journal of Vegetation Science. 3 247-252
• 03 Bakker,  J. P.,, Dijkstra,  M.,, and Russchen,  P.. (1985);  Dispersal, germination and early establishment of halophytes and glycophytes on a grazed and abandoned salt-marsh gradient.  New Phytologist. 101 291-308
• 04 Bertness,  M. D.. (1991);  Interspecific interactions among high marsh perennials in a New England (USA) salt marsh.  Ecology. 72 125-137
• 05 Bertness,  M. D., and Ellison,  A. M.. (1987);  Determinants of pattern in a New England salt marsh plant community.  Ecological Monographs. 57 129-147
• 06 Bertness,  M. D.,, Gough,  L.,, and Shumway,  S. W.. (1992);  Salt tolerance and the distribution of fugitive salt marsh plants.  Ecology. 73 1842-1851
• 07 Bertness,  M. D., and Hacker,  S. D.. (1994);  Physical stress and positive associations among marsh plants.  The American Naturalist. 144 363-372
• 08 Bertness,  M. D., and Shumway,  S. W.. (1993);  Competition and facilitation in marsh plants.  The American Naturalist. 142 718-724
• 09 Bruinzeel,  L. W.,, Van Eerden,  M. R.,, Drent,  R. H.,, and Vulink,  J. T.. (1999) Scaling metabolisable energy intake and daily energy expenditure in relation to the size of herbivorous waterfowl: limits set by available foraging time and digestive performance. Patchwork-patch Use, Habitat Exploitation and Carrying Capacity for Water Birds in Dutch Freshwater Wetlands. Van Eerden, M. R., ed. University of Groningen, The Netherlands; Ph.D.-Thesis 130
• 10 Connell,  J. H., and Slayter,  R. O.. (1977);  Mechanisms of succession in natural communities and their role in community stability and organization.  American Naturalist. 111 1119-1144
• 11 Cooper,  W. S.. (1923);  The recent ecological history of Glacier Bay, Alaska. III. Permanent quadrats at Glacier Bay: An initial report upon a long-period study.  Ecology. 4 355-365
• 12 Cooper,  W. S.. (1939);  A fourth expedition to Glacier Bay, Alaska.  Ecology. 20 130-159
• 13 Cowles,  H. C.. (1899);  The ecological relations of the vegetation on the sand dunes of Lake Michigan.  Botanical Gazette. 27 95-391
• 14 Davidson,  D. W.. (1993);  The effects of herbivory and granivory on terrestrial plant succession.  Oikos. 68 23-35
• 15 Dormann,  C. F.,, Van der Wal,  R.,, and Bakker,  J. P.. (1999) Competition and herbivory intensity during salt-marsh succession: the importance of forb growth strategy, unpublished manuscript. 
• 16 Drent,  R. H., and Van der Wal,  R.. (1999) Cyclic grazing in vertebrates and the manipulation of the food resources. Plants, Herbivores, and Predators. Olff, H., Brown, V. K., and Drent, R. H., eds. Cambridge; Blackwell 299
• 17 Eissa,  F. Z.,, Qualls,  C. W.,, Burrows,  G. E.,, and Lish,  J. W.. (1996);  Effects of feeding Artemisia filifolia and Helenium flexuosum on rabbit cytochrome p450 isozymes.  Veterinary And Human Toxicology. 38 19-23
• 18 Ellison,  A. M.. (1987);  Effects of competition, disturbance, and herbivory on Salicornia europaea. .  Ecology. 3 576-586
• 19 Ellison,  A. M.. (1991);  Ecology of case-bearing moths (Lepidoptera: Coleophoridae) in a New England salt marsh.  Environmental Entomology. 20 857-864
• 20 Feeny,  P.. (1976);  Plant apparency and chemical defense.  Recent Advances in Phytochemistry. 10 1-40
• 21 Glenn-Lewin,  D. C., and Van der Maarel,  E.. (1992) Patterns and processes of vegetation dynamics. Plant Succession. Glenn-Lewin, D. C., Peet, K., and Veblen, T. T., eds. London; Chapman and Hall 59
• 22 Grime,  J. P.. (1979) Plant Strategies and Vegetation Processes. Chichester; John Wiley
• 23 Hartley,  S. E., and Jones,  C. G.. (1997) Plant chemistry and herbivory, or why the world is green. Plant Ecology. Crawley, M. J., ed. Oxford; Blackwell 324
• 24 Huiskes,  A. H. L.,, Koutstaal,  B. P.,, Herman,  P. M. J.,, Beeftink,  W. G.,, Markusse,  M. M.,, and De Munck,  W.. (1995);  Seed dispersal of halophytes in tidal salt marshes.  Journal of Ecology. 83 559-567
• 25 Jefferies,  R. L.,, Davy,  A. J.,, and Rudmik,  T.. (1979) The growth strategies of coastal halophytes. Ecological Processes in Coastal Environments. Jefferies, R. L., Davy, A. J., and Rudmik, T., eds. Cambridge; Cambridge Univ. Press 268
• 26 Jerling,  L., and Andersson,  M.. (1982);  Effects of selective grazing by cattle on the reproduction of Plantago maritima. .  Holarctic Ecology. 5 405-411
• 27 Joenje,  W.. (1985);  The significance of waterfowl grazing in the primary vegetation succession on embanked sandflats.  Vegetatio. 62 37-48
• 28 Kiehl,  K.,, Esselink,  P.,, and Bakker,  J. P.. (1997);  Nutrient limitation and plant species composition in temperate salt marshes.  Oecologia. 111 325-330
• 29 Leendertse,  P. C., and Rozema,  J.. (1997);  Long-term changes (1953 - 1990) in the salt marsh vegetation at the Boschplaat on Terschelling.  Plant Ecology. 132 49-58
• 30 Menard,  S.. (1995) Applied Logistic Regression Analysis. 
• 31 Mulder,  C. P. H., and Ruess,  R. W.. (1998);  Effects of herbivory on arrowgrass: interactions between geese, neighboring plants, and abiotic factors.  Ecological Monographs. 68 275-293
• 32 Narjisse,  H.,, Malechek,  J. C.,, and Olsen,  J. D.. (1997);  Influence of odor and taste of monoterpenoids on food selection by anosmic and intact sheep and goats.  Small Ruminant Research. 23 109-115
• 33 Noble,  I. R., and Slayter,  R. O.. (1980);  The use of vital attributes to predict successional change in plant communities subject to recurrent disturbances.  Vegetatio. 43 5-21
• 34 Olff,  H.,, De Leeuw,  J.,, Bakker,  J. P.,, Platerink,  R. J.,, Van Wijnen,  H. J.,, and De Munck,  W.. (1997);  Vegetation succession and herbivory in a salt marsh: changes induced by sea level rise and silt deposition along an elevational gradient.  Journal of Ecology. 85 799-814
• 35 Pennings,  S. C., and Callaway,  R. M.. (1992);  Salt marsh plant zonation: The relative importance of competition and physical factors.  Ecology. 73 681-690
• 36 Pickett,  S. T. A.. (1987) Space-for-time substitution as an alternative to long-term studies. Long-Term-Studies in Ecology - Approaches and Alternatives. Likens, E., ed. New York; Springer 135
• 37 Pickett,  S. T. A.,, Collins,  S. L.,, and Armesto,  J. J.. (1987);  Models, mechanisms and pathways of succession.  Botanical Review. 53 335-371
• 38 Pigott,  C. D.. (1969) Influence of mineral nutrition on the zonation of flowering plants in coastal salt-marshes. Ecological Aspects of the Mineral Nutrition of Plants. Rorison, I. H., ed. Oxford; Blackwell Scientific Publications 35
• 39 Prop,  J., and Deerenberg,  C.. (1991);  Spring staging in brent geese Branta bernicla: Feeding constraints and the impact of diet on the accumulation of body reserves.  Oecologia. 87 19-28
• 40 Roozen,  A. J. M., and Westhoff,  V.. (1985);  A study on long-term salt marsh succession using permanent plots.  Vegetatio. 61 23-32
• 41 Silvertown,  J. W., and Lovett Doust,  J.. (1994) Introduction to Plant Population Biology. Oxford; Blackwell
• 42 Tilman,  D.. (1986) Evolution and differentiation in terrestrial plant communities: the importance of the soil resource : light gradient. Community Ecology. Diamond, J. M. and Case, T. J., eds. New York; Harper and Row 380
• 43 Tilman,  D.. (1987);  The importance of the mechanisms of interspecific competition.  The American Naturalist. 129 768-774
• 44 Tilman,  D.. (1988) Plant Strategies and the Dynamics and Structure of Plant Communities. Princeton University Press; New Jersey
• 45 Tilman,  D., and Wedin,  D.. (1991);  Dynamics of nitrogen competition between successional grasses.  Ecology. 72 1038-1049
• 46 Van de Koppel,  J.. (1997) Trophic Interactions in Gradients of Primary Productivity. University of Groningen, The Netherlands; PhD-thesis
• 47 Van de Koppel,  J.,, Huisman,  J.,, Van der Wal,  R.,, and Olff,  H.. (1996);  Patterns of herbivory along a productivity gradient: An empirical and theoretical investigation.  Ecology. 77 736-745
• 48 Van der Meijden,  R.,, Weeda,  E. J.,, Holverda,  W. J.,, and Hovenkamp,  P. H.. (1990) Heukels' Flora van Nederland, 21th edition. Groningen; Wolters-Noordhoff
• 49 Van der Wal,  R.,, Egas,  M.,, Van der Veen,  A.,, and Bakker,  J. P.. (1999) Effects of herbivory and competition on growth and reproduction of Triglochin maritima in a gradient of primary productivity, unpublished manuscript. 
• 50 Van der Wal,  R.,, Kunst,  P.,, and Drent,  R. H.. (1998);  Interactions between hare and brent goose in a salt marsh system: evidence for food competition?.  Oecologia. 117 227-234
• 51 Van der Wal,  R.,, Van Wieren,  S.,, Van Wijnen,  H. J.,, Beucher,  O.,, and Bos,  D.. (2000);  On facilitation between herbivores: how Brent geese profit from brown hare.  Ecology.
• 52 Van Wijnen,  H. J., and Bakker,  J. P.. (1997);  Nitrogen accumulation and plant species replacement in three salt marsh systems in the Wadden Sea.  Journal of Coastal Conservation.. 3 19-26
• 53 Van Wijnen,  H. J., and Bakker,  J. P.. (1999);  Nitrogen and phosphorus limitation in a coastal barrier salt marsh: implications for vegetation succession.  Journal of Ecology. 87 265-272
• 54 Van Wijnen,  H. J.,, Bakker,  J. P.,, and De Vries,  Y.. (1997);  Twenty years of salt-marsh succession on the coastal barrier island of Schiermonnikoog (The Netherlands).  Journal of Coastal Conservation. 3 9-18
• 55 Van Wijnen,  H. J.,, Van der Wal,  R.,, and Bakker,  J. P.. (1999);  The impact of small herbivores on nitrogen mineralization rate: consequences for salt-marsh succession.  Oecologia. 118 225-231
• 56 Vince,  S. W., and Snow,  A. A.. (1984);  Plant zonation in an Alaskan salt marsh. Distribution, abundance and environmental factors.  Journal of Ecology. 72 651-667
• 57 White,  T. C. R.. (1984);  The abundance of invertebrate herbivores in¿relation to the availability of nitrogen in stressed food plants.  Oecologia. 63 90-105