Gastroesophageal reflux disease is a common chronic disorder which has a severe effect on the patient’s quality of life. In view of the high cost of medical therapy and the limitations of surgery, a variety of endoscopic techniques have been developed for the treatment of this condition, and these have shown apparently encouraging results, at least in the short term. However, promising results have been obtained in only around two-thirds of patients over a short-term follow-up period of about 6 months. Moreover, several inconsistencies have emerged between the efficacy of this form of treatment in improving symptoms and quality of life and a lack of improvement of objective parameters, such as lower esophageal sphincter pressure and esophageal acid exposure. The authors strongly endorse the need for comprehensive evaluation of clinical evidence on this topic. After an extensive evaluation of existing literature, we suggest that controlled studies are urgently needed in order to clarify the potential of endoscopic therapy, either in terms of cost-effectiveness or in comparison with standard therapy. Meanwhile, with regard to current practice, the use of endoscopic treatment should be limited to clinical trials, which should incorporate the provision of comprehensive and unbiased information to study patients.
References
1
Holloway R H.
The anti-reflux barrier and mechanisms of gastro-oesohageal reflux.
Baillieres Best Pract Res Clin Gastroenterol.
2000;
14
681-699
2
Mittal R K, Holloway R H, Penagini R. et al .
Transient lower esophageal sphincter relaxation.
Gastroenterology.
1995;
109
601-610
3
Hirsch D P, Tytgat G NJ, Boechxstaens G EE.
Transient lower esophageal sphincter relaxations: a pharmacological target for gastro-oesophageal reflux disease?.
[Review article] Aliment Pharmacol Ther.
2002;
16
17-26
4
van Herwaarden M A, Samsom M, Smout A J.
Excess gastroesophageal reflux in patients with hiatus hernia is caused by mechanisms other than transient LES relaxations.
Gastroenterology.
2000;
119
1439-1446
5
Pandolfino J E, Shi G, Curry J. et al .
Esophagogastric junction distensibility: a factor contributing to sphincter incompetence.
Am J Physiol Gastrointest Liver Physiol.
2002;
282
G1052-G1058
6
Ramakrishnan A, Katz P O.
Overview of medical therapy for gastroesophageal disease.
Gastrointest Endosc Clin N Am.
2003;
13
57-68
7
Vigneri S, Termini R, Leandro G. et al .
A comparison of five maintenance therapies for reflux esophagitis.
N Engl J Med.
1995;
333
1106-1110
8
Moss S F, Armstrong D, Arnold R. et al .
GERD 2003: a consensus on the way ahead.
Digestion.
2003;
67
111-117
9
Harewood G C, Gostout C J.
Cost analysis of endoscopic antireflux procedures: endoluminal plication vs. radiofrequency coagulation vs. treatment with a proton pump inhibitor.
Gastrointest Endosc.
2003;
58
493-499
10
Low D E.
Surgery for hiatal hernia and GERD: time for reappraisal and a balanced approach?.
Surg Endosc.
2001;
15
913-917
11
Richter J E.
Importance of bile reflux in Barrett’s esophagus.
Dig Dis.
2000 - 2001;
18
208-216
12
Lundell L, Miettinen P, Myrvold H E. et al .
Continued (5-year) follow-up of a randomized clinical study comparing antireflux surgery and omeprazole in gastroesophageal reflux disease.
J Am Coll Surg.
2001;
192
172-179
13
Kahrilas P J.
Management of GERD: medical versus surgical.
Semin Gastrointest Dis.
2001;
12
3-15
14
Klinkenberg-Knol E C, Festen H P, Jansen J B. et al .
Long-term treatment with omeprazole for refractory reflux esophagitis: efficacy and safety.
Ann Intern Med.
1994;
121
161-167
15
Vakil N, Shaw M, Kirby R.
Clinical effectiveness of laparoscopic fundoplication in a US community.
Am J Med.
2003;
114
1-5
16
Spechler S J, Lee E, Ahnen D. et al .
Long-term outcome of medical and surgical therapies for gastroesophageal reflux diseases: follow-up of a randomized controlled trial.
JAMA.
2001;
285
2331-2338
17
Lafullarde T, Watson D I, Jamieson G G. et al .
Laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication: five-year results and beyond.
Arch Surg.
2001;
136
180-184
18
Hinder R A, Filipi C J, Wetscher G. et al .
Laparoscopic fundoplication is an effective treatment for gastroesophageal reflux disease.
Ann Surg.
1994;
220
472-481
19
Klaus A, Hinder R A, DeVault K R. et al .
Bowel dysfunction after laparoscopic antireflux surgery: incidence, severity, and clinical course.
Am J Med.
2003;
114
6-9
20
Richter J E.
Let the patient beware: the evolving truth about laparoscopic antireflux surgery.
Am J Med.
2003;
114
71-73
21
Zaninotto G, Molena D, Ancona E. and the Study Group for the Laparoscopic Treatment of Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease of the Italian Society of Endoscopic Surgery .
A prospective, multicenter study on laparoscopic treatment of gastroesophageal reflux in Italy: type of surgery, conversions, complications and early results.
Surg Endosc.
2000;
14
282-288
22
Park P, Kjellin T, Swain P.
Results of endoscopic gastroplasty for gastro-esophageal reflux disease [abstract].
Gastroenterology.
2001;
120
A3427
23
Patel V.
Clinical utility of ELGP for GERD disease in private practice [abstract].
Am J Gastroenterol.
2001;
9
A89
24
Rothstein R.
Endoscopic gastroplication for the treatment of GERD: two-year follow-up results [abstract].
Am J Gastroenterol.
2001;
9
A107
25
Liu J, Knapp R, Silk J, Carr-Locke D L.
Treatment of medication-refractory gastroesophageal reflux disease with endoluminal gastroplication [abstract].
Gastroenterology.
2002;
122
A1583
26
Chen Y K, Raijman I, Ben-Menachem T. et al .
Long-term experience with endoluminal gastroplication (ELGP): clinical and economic outcomes of the US multicenter trial [abstract].
Gastroenterology.
2002;
122
A690
27
Abou-Rebyeh H, Hoepffner N, Osmanoglou N. et al .
Endoscopic suturing is able to reduce pathological acid reflux in gastro-esophageal reflux disease [abstract].
Gastroenterology.
2002;
122
A1588
28
Caca K, Schiefke I, Söder H. et al .
Endoluminal gastroplication for gastro-esophageal reflux disease [abstract].
Gastroenterology.
2002;
122
A1888
29
Arts J, Slootmaekers S, Sifrim D. et al .
Endoluminal gastroplication (EndoCinch) in GERD patients refractory to PPI therapy [abstract].
Gastroenterology.
2002;
122
A391
30
Costamagna G, Repici A, Tringali L. et al .
Endoluminal gastroplication (ELGP) with the EndoCinch system: a retrospective analysis of the Italian multicenter experience [abstract].
Dig Liver Dis.
2003;
35 Suppl 4
S40
31
Occhipinti P, Saettone M, Ballarè P. et al .
Endoscopic suturing service (EndoCinch) for treatment of GERD: 1-year follow-up results [abstract].
Dig Liver Dis.
2003;
35 Suppl 4
S53
32
Ben-Menachem T, Chen Y K, Raijman I. et al .
Symptom recurrence after endoluminal gastroplication (ELGP) for GERD: comparison of initial versus repeat ELGP [abstract].
Gastroenterology.
2003;
124
A1737
33
Mahmood Z, McMahon B P, Murphy E. et al .
Quality of life after transesophageal endoscopic plication (EndoCinch) procedure for gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD): a 1-year prospective study [abstract].
Gastroenterology.
2003;
124
A1509
34
Thomson M, Afsal N, Fritscher-Ravens A. et al .
Endoscopic gastroplication for the treatment of pediatric gastro-esophageal reflux disease [abstract].
Gastroenterology.
2003;
124
A563
35
Liu J J, Schamberg N J, Saltzman J R, Carr-Locke J C.
Endoscopic findings post-endoluminal gastroplication (ELGP) [abstract].
Gastroenterology.
2003;
124
A1742
36
Lee L S, Liu J J, Carr-Locke D L, Saltzman J R.
Does the number of sutures affect clinical outcome in endoluminal gastroplication?.
[Abstract] Gastroenterology.
2003;
124
A1739
37
Zhang X, Tack J, Janssens J, Sifrim D.
Acid and non-acid gastroesophageal reflux after endoscopic gastroplication. Evaluation of the antireflux barrier function with 24-hr pH-impedance [abstract].
Gastroenterology.
2003;
124
A748
38
Lee L S, Liu J J, Carr-Locke D L, Saltzman J R.
Effect of endoluminal gastroplication in patients with classic reflux symptoms and minimally abnormal esophageal pH studies [abstract].
Gastroenterology.
2003;
124
A686
39
Ben-Menachem T, Goel S, Zonca M. et al .
Endoscopic surveillance of plications after endoluminal gastroplication (ELGP) for GERD [abstract].
Gastroenterology.
2003;
124
A1731
40
Chen Y K, Raijman I, Ben-Menachem T. et al .
One-year follow up of endoluminal gastroplication (ELGP): clinical and economic outcomes of the US multicenter trial [abstract].
Gastroenterology.
2003;
124
A1887
41
Pleskow D, Rothstein R, Kozarek R. et al .
Endoscopic full-thickness plication for GERD: a multi-center study [abstract].
Gastroenterology.
2003;
124
A671
42
Langhennig-Zabel A, Schiefke I, Neumann S. et al .
Endoscopic gastroplication (EndoCinch) as an alternative option in treatment of GERD: an 18-month follow-up [abstract].
Gastroenterology.
2004;
126
A466
43
Ponchon T, Boyer J, Grimaud J C. et al .
A prospective multicenter phase II study to evaluate the EndoCinch suturing system for the treatment of GERD [abstract].
Gastroenterology.
2004;
126
A922
44
Liu J J, Ookubo R, Saltzman J R.
The clinical efficacy of the endoscopic suturing device for treatment of gastroesophageal reflux [abstract].
Gastroenterology.
2004;
126
A924
45
Schilling D, Kiesslich R, Galle P R, Riemann J F.
First experience with a new endoscopic suture device (ESD) for endoscopic endoluminal therapy for GERD [abstract].
Gastroenterology.
2004;
126
A924
46
Filipi C J, Lehman G A, Rothstein R I. et al .
Transoral, flexible endoscopic suturing for treatment of GERD: a multicenter trial.
Gastrointest Endosc.
2001;
53
416-422
47
Mahmood Z, McMahon B P, Arfin Q. et al .
EndoCinch therapy for gastro-oesophageal reflux disease: a 1-year prospective follow up.
Gut.
2003;
52
34-39
48
Chuttani R, Sud R, Sachdev G. et al .
A novel endoscopic full-thickness plicator for the treatment of GERD: a pilot study.
Gastrointest Endosc.
2003;
58
770-776
49
Pleskow D, Rothstein R, Lo S. et al .
Endoscopic full-thickness plication for the treatment of GERD: a multicenter trial.
Gastrointest Endosc.
2004;
59
163-171
50
Velanovich V, Ben-Menachem T.
Laparoscopic Nissen fundoplicaton after failed endoscopic gastroplication.
Laparoendosc Adv Surg Tech A.
2002;
12
305-308
51
Tam W CE, Schoeman M N, Zhang Q. et al .
Delivery of radiofrequency (RF) energy to the lower esophageal sphincter (LES) and gastric cardia inhibits transient LES relaxations and gastroesophageal reflux in patients with reflux disease.
Gut.
2003;
52
479-485
52
Noar M, Knight S, Bidlack D.
Impaired gastric emptyng in GERD patients improved after radiofrequency (RF) energy delivery to the gastroesophageal junction (Stretta procedure) [abstract].
Gastroenterology.
2002;
122
A558
53
Triadafilopoulos G, DiBaise J K, Nostrant T. et al .
Long-term experience with the Stretta procedure for the treatment of GERD: 6- and 12-month follow-up of the US open label trial [abstract].
Gastroenterology.
2001;
120
A577
54
Mansell D E.
Extended follow-up in patients treated with the Stretta procedure: a report on 29 patients [abstract].
Gastroenterology.
2002;
122
A1889
55
Mavrelis P, Mirro J, Hurwich D. et al .
Use of the Stretta procedure for the treatment of GERD: a community hospital experience [abstract].
Gastroenterology.
2002;
122
A1598
56
Noar M, Lotfi S.
Radio frequency (RF) energy ablation of the cardia and esophagogastric junction corrects GERD-associated gastroparesis [abstract].
Gastroenterology.
2002;
124
A675
57
Noar M D, Knight S, Bidlack D.
Long-term experience with the Stretta procedure in medically refractory GERD patients: the first 14 months [abstract].
Gastroenterology.
2003;
124
A1577
58
Arts J, Van Olmen A, D’Haens G. et al .
Radiofrequency delivery at the gastroesophageal junction in GERD improves acid exposure and symptoms and decreases esophageal sensitivity to acid infusion [abstract].
Gastroenterology.
2003;
124
A148
59
Noar M, Lotfi S.
Long-term experience with the Stretta procedure in the medication-refractory GERD patient [abstract].
Gastroenterology.
2003;
124
A673
60
Meier P N, Nietzschmann T, Akin I. et al .
Improvements in objective GERD parameters after radiofrequency energy delivery (Stretta procedure) [abstract].
Gastroenterology.
2003;
124
A2116
61
Noar M, Xu L, Koch K L.
Effect of radiofrequency ablation on gastric dysrhythmias and gastric emptying in patients with gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) and functional dyspepsia [abstract].
Gastroenterology.
2003;
124
A750
62
Triadafilopoulos G.
Clinical response after Stretta procedure for GERD reflects improvement in esophageal acid exposure [abstract].
Gastroenterology.
2003;
124
A749
63
Noar M, Smith J.
The Stretta procedure improves symptoms and anti-secretory drug use at 2 years, while normalizing gastric emptying function in the majority of impaired subjects [abstract].
Gastroenterology.
2004;
126
A922
64
Triadafilopoulos G, DiBaise J K, Nostrant T T. et al .
Radiofrequency energy delivery to the gastroesophageal junction for the treatment of GERD.
Gastrointest Endosc.
2001;
53
407-415
65
Wolfsen H C, Richards W O.
The Stretta procedure for the treatment of GERD: a registry of 558 patients.
J Laparoendosc Adv Surg Tech A.
2002;
12
395-402
66
Houston H, Khaitan L, Holzman M, Richards W O.
First-year experience of patients undergoing the Stretta procedure.
Surg Endosc.
2003;
17
401-404
67
DiBaise J K, Brand R E, Quigley E M.
Endoluminal delivery of radiofrequency energy to the gastroesophageal junction in uncomplicated GERD: efficacy and potential mechanism of action.
Am J Gastroenterol.
2002;
97
833-842
68
Triadafilopoulos G, DiBaise J K, Nostrant T T. et al .
The Stretta procedure for the treatment of GERD: 6- and 12-month follow-up of the US open label trial.
Gastrointest Endosc.
2002;
55
149-156
69
Richards W O, Scholz S, Khaitan L. et al .
Initial experience with the Stretta procedure for the treatment of gastroesophageal reflux disease.
J Laparoendosc Adv Surg Tech A.
2001;
11
267-273
70
Corley D A, Katz P, Wo J M. et al .
Improvement of gastroesophageal reflux symptoms after radiofrequency energy: a randomized, sham-controlled trial.
Gastroenterology.
2003;
125
668-676
71
Tam W C, Schoeman M N, Zhang Q. et al .
Delivery of radiofrequency energy to the lower oesophageal sphincter and gastric cardia inhibits transient lower oesophageal sphincter relaxations and gastro-oesophageal reflux in patients with reflux disease.
Gut.
2003;
52
479-485
72
Richards W O, Houston H L, Torquati A. et al .
Paradigm shift in the management of gastroesophageal reflux disease.
Ann Surg.
2003;
237
638-647
73
O’Connor K W, Lehman G A.
Endoscopic placement of collagen at the lower esophageal sphincter to inhibit gastroesophageal reflux: a pilot study of 10 medically intractable patients.
Gastrointest Endosc.
1988;
34
106-112
74
Lehman G A, Aisenberg J, Cohen L B. et al .
Enteryx solution, a minimally invasive injectable treatment for GERD: international multicenter trial results [abstract].
Gastroenterology.
2002;
122
A602
75
Lehman G A, Hieston K J, Johnson D. et al .
Enteryx solution, a minimally invasive injectable treatment for GERD: analysis of pH-metry and manometry findings over 12 months [abstract].
Gastroenterology.
2003;
124
A1734
76
Aisenberg J, Johnson D, Cohen L. et al .
Enteryx solution, a minimally invasive injectable treatment for GERD: analysis of X-ray findings over 12 months [abstract].
Gastroenterology.
2003;
124
A1730
77
Neuhaus H, Schumacher B, Preiss C. et al .
Enteryx solution, a minimally invasive injectable treatment for GERD: German multicenter experience [abstract].
Gastroenterology.
2003;
124
A1744
78
Ganz R, Aisenberg J, Cohen L. et al .
Enteryx solution, a minimally invasive injectable treatment for GERD: analysis of endoscopy findings at 12 months [abstract].
Gastroenterology.
2003;
124
A1743
79
Lehman G A, Hieston K J, Aisenberg J. et al .
Enteryx solution, a minimally invasive injectable treatment for GERD: current worldwide multi-center human trial results [abstract].
Gastroenterology.
2003;
124
A672
80
Fockens P, Bruno M J, Boeckxstaens G E, Tytgat G.
Endoscopic removal of the Gatekeeper system prosthesis [abstract].
Gastroenterology.
2002;
122
A1591
81
Gabbrielli A, Emerenziani S, Cicala M. et al .
Endoscopic insertion of hydrogel expandable stent in esophageal submucosa in patients with GERD: the Gatekeeper system experience in 10 patients with 6 months of follow-up [abstract].
Dig Liver Dis.
2003;
35 Suppl 4
S41
82
Metrangolo S, Bertini M, Beroni M. et al .
Endoscopic implant of Enteryx in GERD [abstract].
Dig Liver Dis.
2003;
35 Suppl 4
S53
83
Deviere J, Cohen L B, Aisenberg J. et al .
Predictors of Enterix outcomes at 12 months [abstract].
Gastroenterology.
2004;
126
A922
84
Johnson D A, Aisenberg J, Cohen L B. et al .
Enterix - 24 months clinical safety and effectiveness.
Gastroenterology.
2004;
126
A468
85 Fockens P, Boeckxtaens G E, Gabbrielli A. et al .Gastroenterology 2004. 126: A921
86
Johnson D A, Ganz R, Aisenberg J. et al .
Endoscopic implantation of Enteryx for treatment of GERD: 12-month results of a prospective, multicenter trial.
Am J Gastroenterol.
2003;
98
1921-1930
87
Deviere J, Pastorelli A, Louis H. et al .
Endoscopic implantation of a biopolymer in the lower esophageal sphincter for gastroesophageal reflux: a pilot study.
Gastrointest Endosc.
2002;
55
335-341
88
Feretis C, Nenakis P, Domopoulos C. et al .
Endoscopic treatment of Plexigas (PNMA) microspheres for the treatment of GERD.
Gastrointest Endosc.
2001;
53
423-426
89
Fockens P, Bruno J M, Gabbrielli A. et al .
Endoscopic augmentation of the lower esophageal sphincter for the treatment of gastroesophageal reflux disease: multicenter study of the Gatekeeper reflux repair system.
Endoscopy.
2004;
36
682-689
90
Tintillier M, Chaput A, Kirch L. et al .
Esophageal abscess complicating endoscopic treatment of refractory gastroesophageal reflux disease by Enteryx injection: a first case report.
Am J Gastroenterol.
2004;
99
1856-1858
91
Rothstein R I .
Endoscopy therapy for gastroesophageal reflux disease.
Gastrointest Endosc Clin N Am.
2003;
13
1-226
92
Arts J, Tack J, Galmiche J P.
Endoscopic antireflux procedures.
Gut.
2004;
53
1207-1214
93
Kahrilas P J.
Radiofrequency energy treatment of GERD.
Gastroenterology.
2003;
125
970-973
1 These authors contributed equally to the preparation of the manuscript
2 These authors were involved equally in the critical review of the final draft
V. Annese, M.D.
U.O. Gastroenterologia · Ospedale CSS-IRCCS
Viale Cappuccini 1 · 71013 San Giovanni Rotondo · Italy
Fax: +39-882-411879/705
Email: v.annese@operapadrepio.it