Possible Artefacts in the in vitro Determination of Antimalarial Activity of Natural Products that Incorporate into Lipid Bilayer: Apparent Antiplasmodial Activity of Dehydroabietinol, a Constituent of Hyptis suaveolens

Abstract

Dehydroabietinol isolated from Hyptis suaveolens (L.) Poit. was found to inhibit growth of chloroquine-sensitive as well as chloroquine-resistant strains of Plasmodium falciparum cultivated in erythrocytes in vitro (IC₅₀ 26 - 27 µM). However, erythrocytes exposed to dehydroabietinol were transformed in a dose-dependent manner towards spherostomatocytic forms with concomitant formation of endovesicles, as disclosed by transmission electron microscopy. The erythrocyte shape alterations caused by dehydroabietinol correlated well with its apparent IC₅₀ value. Thus, dehydroabietinol incorporates into the erythrocyte membrane, and since invasion and survival of Plasmodium parasites is known to depend on the function of the erythrocyte membrane, the observed antiplasmodial effect of dehydroabietinol is presumably an indirect effect on the host cell. Because of these findings, microscopic investigations should be generally used to support claims of antimalarial effects of apolar natural products.

References

• 1 Azevedo N R, Campos I F, Ferreira H D, Portes T A, Santos S C, Seraphin J C, Paula J R, Ferri P H. Chemical variability in the essential oil of Hyptis suaveolens .  Phytochemistry. 2001;  57 733-6
• 2 Asekun O T, Ekundayo O. Essential oil constituents of Hyptis suaveolens (L.) Poit. (bush tea) leaves from Nigeria.  Journal of Essential Oil Research. 2000;  12 227-30
• 3 Manchand P S, White J D, Fayos J, Clardy J. Structures of suaveolic acid and suaveolol.  Journal of Organic Chemistry. 1974;  39 2306-8
• 4 Rao K VR, Rao L JM, Rao N SP. An A-ring contracted triterpenoid from Hyptis suaveolens .  Phytochemistry. 1990;  29 1326-9
• 5 Mukherjee K S, Mukherjee R K, Ghosh P K. Chemistry of Hyptis suaveolens: a pentacyclic triterpene.  Journal of Natural Products. 1984;  47 377-8
• 6 Misra T N, Singh R S, Upadhyay J. A natural triterpene acid from Hyptis suaveolens .  Phytochemistry. 1983;  22 2557-8
• 7 Palsson K, Jaenson T GT. Comparison of plant products and pyrethroid-treated bed nets for protection against mosquitoes (Diptera: Culicidae) in Guinea Bissau, West Africa.  Journal of Medical Entomology. 1999;  36 144-8
• 8 Kutney J P, Han K. Studies with plant-cell cultures of the Chinese herbal plant, Tripterygium wilfordii. Isolation and characterization of diterpenes.  Recueil des Travaux Chimiques des Pays-Bas. 1996;  115 77-93
• 9 Rezvukhin A I, Solomennikova I V, Shmidt E N, Avdyukova N V. ¹³C NMR spectroscopy of natural products. 2. Diterpenes of the dehydroabietane series.  Bulletin of the Academy of Sciences of USSR, Division of Chemical Sciences (English Translation). 1979;  28 2490-6
• 10 Fieser L F, Campbell W P. Hydroxyl and amino derivatives of dehydroabietic acid and dehydroabietinol.  Journal of the American Chemical Society. 1939;  61 2528-34
• 11 Carman R M, Deeth H C. Diterpenoids. XIV. 4-Epidehydroabietic acid from the oleoresin of Callitris columellaris F. Muell.  Australian Journal of Chemistry. 1967;  20 2789-93
• 12 Ulubelen A, Topcu G. Abietane diterpenoids from Salvia pomifera .  Phytochemistry. 1992;  31 3949-51
• 13 Fraga B M, Mestres T, Diaz C E, Arteaga J M. Dehydroabietane diterpenes from Nepeta teydea .  Phytochemistry. 1994;  35 1509-12
• 14 Kirk K. Membrane transport in the malaria-infected erythrocyte.  Physiological Reviews. 2001;  81 495-537
• 15 Ziegler H L, Stærk D, Christensen J, Hviid L, Hägerstrand H, Jaroszewski J W. In vitro Plasmodium falciparum drug-sensitivity assay: Inhibition of parasite growth by incorporation of stomatocytogenic amphiphiles into the erythrocyte membrane. Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy, in press
• 16 Sheetz M P, Alhanaty E. Bilayer sensor model of erythrocyte shape control.  Annals of New York Academy of Sciences. 1983;  416 58-63
• 17 McColm A A, Hommel M, Trigg P I. Inhibition of malaria parasite invasion into erythrocytes pretreated with membrane active drugs.  Molecular and Biochemical Parasitology. 1980;  1 119-27
• 18 Hadley T J, Saul A, Lamont G, Hudson D E, Miller L H, Kidson C. Resistance of Melanesian elliptocytes (ovalocytes) to invasion by Plasmodium knowlesi and Plasmodium falciparum malaria parasites in vitro .  Journal of Clinical Investigations. 1983;  71 780-2
• 19 Dluzewski A R, Rangachari  K, Gratzer W B, Wilson R JM. Inhibition of malarial invasion of red cells by chemical and immunochemical linking of spectrin molecules.  British Journal of Haematology. 1983;  55 629-37
• 20 Bessis M. Red cell shapes, an illustrated classification and its rationale. In: Bessis M, Weed RI, Leblond PF, editors Red cell shape; physiology, pathology, ultrastructure. Heidelberg; Springer-Verlag 1973: 1-24
• 21 Christensen S B, Kharazmi A. Antimalarial natural products. In: Trigala C, editor Bioactive compounds from natural sources, isolation, characterisation and biological properties. London; Taylor & Francis 2001: 380-431
• 22 Sairafianpour M, Christensen J, Stærk D, Budnik B A, Kharazmi A, Bagherzadeh K, Jaroszewski J W. Leishmanicidal, antiplasmodial and cytotoxic activity of novel diterpenoid 1,2-quinones from Perovskia abrotanoides: new source of tanshinones.  Journal of Natural Products. 2001;  64 1398-403
• 23 Stærk D, Christensen J, Lemmich E, Duus J Ø, Olsen C E, Jaroszewski J W. Cytotoxic activity of some phenanthroindolizidine N-oxide alkaloids from Cynanchum vincetoxicum .  Journal of Natural Products. 2000;  63 1584-6