RSS-Feed abonnieren
![](/products/assets/desktop/img/oa-logo.png)
DOI: 10.1055/s-0041-1726489
Primary Care Informatics Response to Covid-19 Pandemic: Adaptation, Progress, and Lessons from Four Countries with High ICT Development
![](https://www.thieme-connect.de/media/10.1055-s-00034612/202101/lookinside/thumbnails/10-1055-s-0041-1726489_liaw-1.jpg)
Summary
Objective: Internationally, primary care practice had to transform in response to the COVID pandemic. Informatics issues included access, privacy, and security, as well as patient concerns of equity, safety, quality, and trust. This paper describes progress and lessons learned.
Methods: IMIA Primary Care Informatics Working Group members from Australia, Canada, United Kingdom and United States developed a standardised template for collection of information. The template guided a rapid literature review. We also included experiential learning from primary care and public health perspectives.
Results: All countries responded rapidly. Common themes included rapid reductions then transformation to virtual visits, pausing of non-COVID related informatics projects, all against a background of non-standardized digital development and disparate territory or state regulations and guidance. Common barriers in these four and in less-resourced countries included disparities in internet access and availability including bandwidth limitations when internet access was available, initial lack of coding standards, and fears of primary care clinicians that patients were delaying care despite the availability of televisits.
Conclusions: Primary care clinicians were able to respond to the COVID crisis through telehealth and electronic record enabled change. However, the lack of coordinated national strategies and regulation, assurance of financial viability, and working in silos remained limitations. The potential for primary care informatics to transform current practice was highlighted. More research is needed to confirm preliminary observations and trends noted.
Keywords
Telemedicine - Primary Health Care - health policy - public health - severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2Publikationsverlauf
Artikel online veröffentlicht:
21. April 2021
© 2021. IMIA and Thieme. This is an open access article published by Thieme under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonDerivative-NonCommercial License, permitting copying and reproduction so long as the original work is given appropriate credit. Contents may not be used for commercial purposes, or adapted, remixed, transformed or built upon. (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/)
Georg Thieme Verlag KG
Rüdigerstraße 14, 70469 Stuttgart, Germany
-
References
- 1 Liaw ST, Zhou R, Ansari S, Gao J. Digital Health Profile and Maturity Assessment Toolkit: co-creation in the Pacific Islands. J Am Med Inform Assoc 2020; ocaa255
- 2 Webster P. Virtual health care in the era of COVID-19. Lancet 2020; 395 (10231): 1180-1
- 3 Maldonado JMSdV, Marques AB, Cruz A. Telemedicine: challenges to dissemination in Brazil. Cadernos de Saúde Pública [Internet]. 2016 [cited 2021 Feb]; 32(Suppl2):e00155615. Available from: https://www.scielo.br/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S0102-311X2016001402005
- 4 Grönqvist H, Olsson EMG, Johansson B, Held C, Sjöström J, LindahlNorberg A. et al. Fifteen Challenges in Establishing a Multidisciplinary Research Program on eHealth Research in a University Setting: A Case Study. J Med Internet Res 2017; 19 (05) e173
- 5 Champion C, Kuziemsky C, Affleck E, Alvarez GG. A systems approach for modeling health information complexity. International Journal of Information Management 2019; 49: 343-54
- 6 Jonnagaddala J, Guo GN, Batongbacal S, Marcelo A, Liaw ST. Adoption of enterprise architecture for healthcare in AeHIN member countries. BMJ Health Care Inform 2020; 27 (01) e100136
- 7 International Telecommunication Union. Measuring digital development. Facts and figures 2020. Geneva: Internatiomal Telecommunication Union; 2020
- 8 Duckett S. What should primary care look like after the COVID-19 pandemic?. Aust J Prim Health 2020; 26 (03) 207-11
- 9 Desborough J, Dykgraaf SH, deToca L, Davis S, Roberts L, Kelaher C. et al. Australia’s national COVID 19 primary care response. Med J Aust 2020; 213 (03) 104-106.e101
- 10 Snoswell CL, Caffery LJ, Haydon HM, Thomas EE, Smith AC. Telehealth uptake in general practice as a result of the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic. Aust Health Rev 2020; 44 (05) 737-40
- 11 Snoswell C, Caffery L, Hobson G, Taylor ML, Haydon HM, Thomas E. et al. Telehealth and coronavirus: Medicare Benefits Schedule (MBS) activity in Australia. Centre for Online Health, The University of Queensland; 2020. Updated May 19, 2020 [cited 2021 Feb 7]. Available from: https://coh.centre.uq.edu.au/telehealth-and-coronavirus-medicare-benefits-schedule-mbs-activity-australia
- 12 Pearce C, McLeod A, Gardner K, Supple J, Epstein D, Buttery J. THE GP Insights Series no 7: Primary Care and SARS-CoV-2: The first 40 weeks of the pandemic year. Melbourne: Outcome Health; 2020
- 13 Clark M, Brewster D, Jones L, Dhaliwal JS, Teng J. Uncertainty and fear: aged care in a time of COVID-19. MJA Insights+ 2020(44)
- 14 Baird A. Video communication for GPs and patients. MJA Insight+ 2020(32)
- 15 Car J, Koh GCH, Foong PS, Wang CJ. Video consultations in primary and specialist care during the covid-19 pandemic and beyond. BMJ 2020; 371: m3945
-
16 Medicare Australia. Medicare Benefits Schedule (MBS) Online. Medicare Australia [Internet]; 2020. [cited 2020 Nov 8]. Available from: http://www.mbsonline.gov.au/internet/mbsonline/publishing.nsf/Content/Home
-
17 The Royal Australian College of General Practitioners. General Practice: Health of the Nation 2020. East Melbourne, Vic: RACGP;2020
-
18 Meidibank Australia. Telehealth support. Look after your health from home with Telehealth. Medibank [Internet]; 2020 [cited 2020 Nov 14]. Available from: https://www.medibank.com.au/health-support/hospital-assist/covid19/telehealth-services/
- 19 Celler B, Varnfield M, Nepal S, Sparks R, Li J, Jayasena R. Impact of At-Home Telemonitoring on Health Services Expenditure and Hospital Admissions in Patients With Chronic Conditions: Before and After Control Intervention Analysis. JMIR Med Inform 2017; 5 (03) e29
-
20 The University of New South Wales. Total Cardiac Care. UNSW Graduate School of Biomedical Engineering [Internet]; 2020 [cited 2020]. Available from: https://apps.apple.com/au/app/total-cardiac-care/id1437138162
-
21 Australian Government Department of Health. Electronic prescribing. Australian Government Department of Health [Internet]; 2020. Updated 13 Nov 2020. [cited 2020 Nov 15]. Available from: https://www.health.gov.au/initiatives-and-programs/electronic-prescribing
-
22 The University of Queensland Centre for Online Health. Telehealth and coronavirus: Medicare Benefits Schedule (MBS) activity in Australia. University of Queensland [Internet]; 2020 [cited 2020 Nov 14]. Available from: https://coh.centre.uq.edu.au/telehealth-and-coronavirus-medicare-benefits-schedule-mbs-activity-australia
- 23 Helsper CW, Campbell C, Emery J, Neal RD, Li L, Rubin G. et al. Cancer has not gone away: A primary care perspective to support a balanced approach for timely cancer diagnosis during COVID-19. Eur J Cancer Care (Engl) 2020; 29 (05) e13290
- 24 Wright M, Versteeg R, Hall J. General practice’s early response to the COVID-19 pandemic. Aust Health Rev 2020; 44 (05) 733-6
-
25 Canadian Medical Association-Royal College of Physicians & Surgeons of Canada-College of Family Physicians of Canada. How to navigate a virtual care visit: patient guide. Canadian Medical Association [Internet]; 2020 [cited 2020 Nov 14]. Available from: https://www.cma.ca/how-navigate-virtual-care-visit-patient-guide
-
26 Canadian Healthcare Technology. SK deploys COVID-19 e-referral and intake system. Canadian Healthcare Technology [Internet); 2020. [cited 2020 Nov 14]. Available from: https://www.canhealth.com/2020/08/19/sk-deploys-covid-19-e-referral-and-intake-system/
-
27 Island Health. Hospital at Home - Victoria General Hospital Prototype. Island Health [Internet]; 2020. [cited 2020 Nov 14]. Available from: https://www.islandhealth.ca/our-services/hospital-home-services/hospital-home
- 28 Huston P, Campbell J, Russell G, Goodyear-Smith F, PhillipsJr RL, vanWeel C. et al. COVID-19 and primary care in six countries. BJGP Open 2020;4(4):bjgpopen20X101128
- 29 Bhattacharyya O, Agarwal P. Adapting primary care to respond to COVID-19. Can Fam Physician 2020
-
30 Canadian Medical Association. What Canadians think about virtual health care. Canadian Medical Association [Internet]; 2020. [cited 2020 Nov 14]. Available from: https://www.cma.ca/sites/default/files/pdf/virtual-care/cma-virtual-care-public-poll-june-2020-e.pdf
-
31 Canadian Institute for Health Information. Physician billing codes in response to COVID-19. Canadian Institute for Health Information [Internet]; 2020. [cited 2020 Nov 14]. Available from: https://www.cihi.ca/en/physician-billing-codes-in-response-to-covid-19
-
32 Ontario Health Insurance Plan. Bulletin Number: 4745: Keeping Health Care Providers informed of payment, policy or program changes. Ministry of Health [Internet]; 2020. Updated 2020 Mar 13. [cited 2021 Feb 7]. Available from: http://www.health.gov.on.ca/en/pro/programs/ohip/bulletins/4000/bul4745.aspx
- 33 Wong S. The Primary and Integrated Health Care Innovations Network. Quick COVID-19 Primary Care Survey of Clinicians: Summary of the pan-Canadian survey of frontline primary care clinicians’ experience with COVID-19, series 6-11. In: Annals of Family Medicine, COVID-19 Collection. Deepblue: University of Michigan; 2020
-
34 Ontario College of Family Physicians. Family Doctors are Open and Here for Care, and More. Ontario College of Family Physicians [Internet]; 2020. [cited 2020 Nov 14]. Available from: https://www.ontariofamilyphysicians.ca/news-features/family-medicine-news/∼188-Family-Doctors-are-Open-and-Here-for-Care-and-More
- 35 Glauser W. Virtual care is here to stay, but major challenges remain. CMAJ 2020; 192 (30) E868-E869
-
36 Deloitte Centre for Health Solutions. COVID-19 Virtual care is here to stay. Deloitte Canada; 2020
- 37 Gagnon MP, Julie D, Fortin JP. A survey in Alberta and Quebec of the telehealth applications that physicians need. J Telemed Telecare 2007; 13 (07) 352-6
- 38 O’Gorman LD, Hogenbirk JC, Warry W. Clinical Telemedicine Utilization in Ontario over the Ontario Telemedicine Network. Telemed J E Health 2015; 22 (06) 473-9
- 39 Bhatia RS, Falk W, Jamieson T, Piovesan C, Shaw J. Virtual health care is having its moment. Rules will be needed. Healthydebate [Internet]; 2020. [cited 2020 Nov 14]. Available from: https://healthydebate.ca/opinions/virtual-health-care-rules-covid
- 40 Appia V. What does the future of telemedicine look like in Ontario after COVID-19? Toronto.com [Internet]; 2020. [cited 2020 Nov 14]. Available from: https://www.toronto.com/news-story/9966360-what-does-the-future-of-telemedicine-look-like-in-ontario-after-covid-19-/
- 41 MacLeod M. Virtual health care is ‘not the answer for everything,’ critics warn. CTV News. Coronavirus updates Web site [Internet]; 2020. [cited 2020 Nov 14]. Available from: https://www.ctvnews.ca/health/coronavirus/virtual-health-care-is-not-the-answer-for-everything-critics-warn-1.4939283
- 42 Bhatti S, Commisso E, Rayner J. A Rapid Primary Healthcare Response to COVID-19: An Equity-Based and Systems- Thinking Approach to Care Ensuring that No One Is Left Behind. Healthc Q 2020; 23 (03) 29-33
- 43 Bhyat R. Canada’s ‘new normal’ must include virtual care. Healthydebate [Internet]; 2020. [cited 2020 Nov 14]. Available from: https://healthydebate.ca/opinions/new-normal-include-virtual-care
- 44 Mosnaim GS, Stempel H, VanSickle D, Stempel DA. The Adoption and Implementation of Digital Health Care in the Post–COVID-19 Era. J Allergy Clin Immunol Pract 2020; 8 (08) 2484-6
- 45 Schade CP, Sullivan FM, deLusignan S, Madeley J. e-Prescribing, Efficiency, Quality: Lessons from the Computerization of UK Family Practice. J Am Med Inform Assoc 2006; 13 (05) 470-5
- 46 deLusignan S, Carlyon T, Lalvani A. Removing the handle of the Broad Street pump: measures to slow the spread of covid-19 in primary care teams. BMJ 2020; 369: m1841
- 47 Dyer C. Covid-19: Doctors make bid for public inquiry into lack of PPE for frontline workers. BMJ 2020; 369: m1905
- 48 Joy M, McGagh D, Jones N. et al. Reorganisation of primary care for older adults during COVID-19: a cross-sectional database study in the UK. Br J Gen Pract 2020; 70 (697): e540
- 49 deLusignan S, Williams J. To monitor the COVID-19 pandemic we need better quality primary care data. BJGP Open 2020;4(2):bjgpopen20X101070
- 50 deLusignan S, Dorward J, Correa A. et al. Risk factors for SARS-CoV-2 among patients in the Oxford Royal College of General Practitioners Research and Surveillance Centre primary care network: a cross-sectional study. Lancet Infect Dis 2020; 20 (09) 1034-42
- 51 Joy M, Hobbs FDR, McGagh D, Akinyemi O, deLusignan S. Excess mortality from COVID-19 in an English sentinel network population. Lancet Infect Dis 2020;S1473-3099(20)30632-0
- 52 deLusignan S, Joy M, Oke J, McGagh D, Nicholson B, Sheppard J. et al. Disparities in the excess risk of mortality in the first wave of COVID-19: Cross sectional study of the English sentinel network. J Infect 2020; 81 (05) 785-92
- 53 Joy M, Hobbs FDR, Bernal JL, Sherlock J, Amirthalingam G, McGagh D. et al. Excess mortality in the first COVID pandemic peak: cross-sectional analyses of the impact of age, sex, ethnicity, household size, and long-term conditions in people of known SARS-Cov-2 status in England. Br J Gen Pract 2020; bjgp20X713393
- 54 de Lusignan S, LopezBernal J, Zambon M, Akinyemi O, Amirthalingam G, Andrews N. et al. Emergence of a Novel Coronavirus (COVID-19): Protocol for Extending Surveillance Used by the Royal College of General Practitioners Research and Surveillance Centre and Public Health England. JMIR Public Health Surveill 2020; 6 (02) e18606
-
55
deLusignan S,
Bernal J,
Byford R,
Amirthalingam G.
Seasonal influenza surveillance and vaccine effectiveness at a time of co-circulating COVID-19: Oxford-Royal College of General Practitioners (RCGP) Research and Surveillance Centre (RSC) and Public Health England (PHE) protocol for winter 2020/21 (Preprint). 2020
-
56 University of Oxford CIHORG. RCGP RSC COVID-19 Observatory and Coding Guidelines. University of Oxford [Internet]; 2021. [cited 2021 Feb 13]. Available from: https://orchid.phc.ox.ac.uk/index.php/cov-19/
- 57 Koonin LM, Hoots B, Tsang CA, Leroy Z, Farris K, Jolly T. et al. Trends in the Use of Telehealth During the Emergence of the COVID-19 Pandemic ’ United States, January–March 2020. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep 2020; 69 (43) 1595-9
- 58 Patel S, Mehrotra A, Huskamp H, Uscher-Pines L, Ganguli I, Barnett ML. Trends in outpatient care delivery and telemedicine during the COVID-19 pandemic in the US. JAMA Intern Med 2021; 181 (03) 388-91
- 59 Reddy A, Gunnink E, Deeds SA, Hagan SL, Heyworth L, Mattras TF. et al. A rapid mobilization of ‘virtual’ primary care services in response to COVID-19 at Veterans Health Administration. Healthc (Amst) 2020; 8 (04) 100464-100464
- 60 Spelman JF, Brienza R, Walsh RF, Drost P, Schwartz AR, Kravetz JD. et al. A Model for Rapid Transition to Virtual Care, VA Connecticut Primary Care Response to COVID-19. J Gen Intern Med 2020; 35 (10) 3073-6
- 61 Sinha S, Kern LM, Gingras LF, Reshetnyak E, Tung J, Pelzman F. et al. Implementation of Video Visits During COVID-19: Lessons Learned From a Primary Care Practice in New York City. Front Public Health 2020; 8: 514-22
- 62 Srinivasan M, Asch S, Vilendrer S, CrandallThomas S, Bajra R, Barman L. et al. Qualitative Assessment of Rapid System Transformation to Primary Care Video Visits at an Academic Medical Center. Ann Intern Med 2020; 173 (07) 527-35
- 63 Smith WR, Atala AJ, Terlecki RP, Kelly EE, Matthews CA. Implementation Guide for Rapid Integration of an Outpatient Telemedicine Program During the COVID-19 Pandemic. J Am Coll Surg 2020; 231 (02) 216-222.e2
- 64 Reeves JJ, Hollandsworth HM, Torriani FJ, Taplitz R, Abeles S, Tai-Seale M. et al. Rapid Response to COVID-19: Health Informatics Support for Outbreak Management in an Academic Health System. J Am Med Inform Assoc 2020; 27 (06) 853-9
- 65 Hron JD, Parsons CR, Williams LA, Harper MB, Bourgeois FC. Rapid Implementation of an Inpatient Telehealth Program during the COVID-19 Pandemic. Appl Clin Inform 2020; 11 (03) 452-9
- 66 Sinha S, Kern LM, Gingras LF, Tung J, Pelzman F. et al. Implementation of Video Visits During COVID-19: Lessons Learned From a Primary Care Practice in New York City. Front Public Health 2020; 8: 514
- 67 Ranney ML, Griffeth V, Jha AK. Critical Supply Shortages ’ The Need for Ventilators and Personal Protective Equipment during the Covid-19 Pandemic. N Engl J Med 2020; 382 (18) e41
- 68 Brodwin E. With covid-19 delaying routine care chronic disease startups brace for a slew of complications. Health Tech 2020 Apr 14 [cited 2020 Nov 14]. Available from: https://www.statnews.com/2020/04/14/with-covid-19-delaying-routine-care-chronic-disease-startups-brace-for-a-slew-of-complications/
- 69 Jaffe DH, Lee L, Huynh S, Haskell TP. Health Inequalities in the Use of Telehealth in the United States in the Lens of COVID-19. Popul Health Manag 2020; 23 (05) 368-77
- 70 Summers-Gabr NM. Rural–urban mental health disparities in the United States during COVID-19. Psychol Trauma 2020; 12 (S1): S222-S224
- 71 Basu S, Phillips RS, Phillips R, Peterson LE, Landon BE. Primary Care Practice Finances In The United States Amid The COVID-19 Pandemic. Health Aff (Millwood) 2020; 39 (09) 1605-14
- 72 United States Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS). Home health agencies: CMS flexibilities to fight Covid-19. Washington DC: Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services. 2020
-
73 US Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Medicare telemedicine health care provider fact sheet [Internet] 2020. Updated 2020 March 17 [cited 2021 Feb 6]. Available from: https://www.cms.gov/newsroom/fact-sheets/medicare-telemedicine-health-care-provider-fact-sheet
- 74 Robbins R, Brodwin E. As insurers move this week to stop waiving telehealth copays, patients may have to pay more for virtual care. STAT+. Health Tech Web site [Internet]; 2020. [cited 2020 Nov 14]. Available from: https://www.statnews.com/2020/09/29/united-healthcare-anthem-telemedicine-coverage-insurers/
- 75 Subbian V, Solomonides A, Clarkson M, Rahimzadeh VN, Petersen C, Schreiber R. et al. Ethics and informatics in the age of COVID-19: challenges and recommendations for public health organization and public policy. J Am Med Inform Med Assoc 2021; 28 (01) 184-9
- 76 Chen C. America Doesn’t Have a Coherent Strategy for Asymptomatic Testing. It Needs One. In: ProPublica, Vol 20212020
- 77 Katzow MW, Steinway C, Jan S. Telemedicine and Health Disparities During COVID-19. Pediatrics 2020; 146 (02) e20201586
- 78 Krist AH, DeVoe JE, Cheng A, Ehrlich T, Jones SM. Redesigning Primary Care to Address the COVID-19 Pandemic in the Midst of the Pandemic. Ann Fam Med 2020; 18 (04) 349-54
- 79 Lin S, Sattler A, Smith M. Retooling Primary Care in the COVID-19 Era.. Mayo Clinic Proceedings 2020; 95 (09) 1831-4
- 80 Mehrotra A, Bhatia RS, Snoswell CL. Paying for Telemedicine After the Pandemic. JAMA 2021; 325 (05) 431-2
- 81 Godinho MA, Jonnagaddala J, Gudi N, Islam R, Narasimhan P, Liaw ST. mHealth for Integrated People-Centred Health Services in the Western Pacific: A Systematic Review. Int J Med Inform 2020; 142: 104259
- 82 World Health Organisation & International Telecommunication Union. WHO-ITU: National eHealth Strategy Toolkit. Geneva: WHO & ITU; 2012
-
83 World Health Organisation. Early Warning, Alert and Response System (EWARS). WHO [Internet], 2020. [cited 2020 Nov 14]. Available from: https://www.who.int/emergencies/surveillance/early-warning-alert-and-response-system-ewars
- 84 Venkata-Subramani M, Roman J. The Coronavirus Response in India - World’s Largest Lockdown. Am J Med Sci 2020:S0002-9629(0020)30351-30357
- 85 Agarwal N, Jain P, Pathak R, Gupta R. Telemedicine in India: A tool for transforming health care in the era of COVID-19 pandemic. J Educ Health Promot 2020; 9: 190-190
- 86 Dinakaran D, Basavarajappa C, Manjunatha N, Kumar CN, Math SB. Telemedicine Practice Guidelines and Telepsychiatry Operational Guidelines, India’A Commentary. Indian J Psychol Med 2020; 42 (5_suppl): 1S-3S
-
87 World Health Organisation. ITU-WHO Joint Statement: Unleashing information technology to defeat COVID-19. ITU-WHO [Internet]; 2020. [cited 2020 Nov 14]. Available from: https://www.who.int/news/item/20-04-2020-itu-who-joint-statement-unleashing-information-technology-to-defeat-covid-19
- 88 Friedman U. One Country Has Jumped Ahead on Vaccinations Israel has vaccinated six times more of its population than the United States. Can others learn from its success?. The Atlantic 2021
- 89 Waitzberg R, Davidovitch N. Israel’s vaccination rollout: short term success, but questions for the long run. theBMJopinion 2021
- 90 Fisk M, Livingstone A, Pit SW. Telehealth in the Context of COVID-19: Changing Perspectives in Australia, the United Kingdom, and the United States. J Med Internet Res 2020; 22 (06) e19264
- 91 Butler SM. Four COVID-19 Lessons for Achieving Health Equity. JAMA Health Forum 2020; 1 (11) e201370-e201370
- 92 Wilkinson MD, Dumontier M, Aalbersberg IJ, Appleton G, Axton M, Baak A. et al. The FAIR Guiding Principles for scientific data management and stewardship. Sci Data 2016; 3: 160018