Semin Liver Dis 2020; 40(03): 264-281
DOI: 10.1055/s-0040-1713118
Review Article

Machine Perfusion: Cold versus Warm, versus Neither. Update on Clinical Trials

E. Bonaccorsi-Riani*
1   Abdominal Transplant Unit, Cliniques Universitaires Saint-Luc, Université catholique de Louvain, Brussels, Belgium
2   Pôle de Chirurgie Expérimentale et Transplantation, Université Catholique de Louvain, Brussels, Belgium
,
I.M.A. Brüggenwirth*
3   Department of Surgery, University Medical Center Groningen, University of Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands
,
J.E. Buchwald
4   Division of Transplant, Department of Surgery, UMass Memorial Medical Center, University of Massachusetts, Worcester, Massachusetts
,
S. Iesari
2   Pôle de Chirurgie Expérimentale et Transplantation, Université Catholique de Louvain, Brussels, Belgium
5   Department of Biotechnological and Applied Clinical Sciences, University of L'Aquila, L'Aquila, Italy
,
P.N. Martins
4   Division of Transplant, Department of Surgery, UMass Memorial Medical Center, University of Massachusetts, Worcester, Massachusetts
› Author Affiliations

Abstract

Machine perfusion (MP) preservation is potentially one of the most significant improvements in the field of liver transplantation in the last 20 years, and it has been considered a promising strategy for improved preservation and ex situ evaluation of extended criteria donor (ECD) organs. However, MP preservation adds significant cost and logistical considerations to liver transplantation. MP protocols are mainly classified according to the perfusion temperature with hypothermic machine perfusion (HMP) and normothermic machine perfusion (NMP) being the two categories most studied so far. After extensive preclinical work, MP entered the clinical setting, and there are now several studies that demonstrated feasibility and safety. However, because of the limited quality of clinical trials, there is no compelling evidence of superiority in preservation quality, and liver MP is still considered experimental in most countries. MP preservation is moving to a more mature phase, where ongoing and future studies will bring new evidence in order to confirm their superiority in terms of clinical outcomes, organ utilization, and cost-effectiveness. Here, we present an overview of all preclinical MP studies using discarded human livers and liver MP clinical trials, and discuss their results. We describe the different perfusion protocols, pitfalls in MP study design, and provide future perspectives. Recent trials in liver MP have revealed unique challenges beyond those seen in most clinical studies. Randomized trials, correct trial design, and interpretation of data are essential to generate the data necessary to prove if MP will be the new gold standard method of liver preservation.

Authors' Contributions

E.B-R., I.M.A.B., J.B., S.I., and P.N.M. contributed to conception and design, acquisition of data, and analysis and interpretation of data. E.B.-R., I.M.A.B., and P.N.M. drafted the article and revised it critically for important intellectual content. P.N.M. approved the final version to be published.


* These authors contributed equally to this work.




Publication History

Article published online:
18 June 2020

© 2020. Thieme. All rights reserved.

Thieme Medical Publishers
333 Seventh Avenue, New York, NY 10001, USA.

 
  • References

  • 1 Mazzaferro V, Battiston C, Sposito C. Pro (with caution): extended oncologic indications in liver transplantation. Liver Transpl 2018; 24 (01) 98-103
  • 2 Schaefer B, Zoller H, Schneeberger S. Con: liver transplantation for expanded criteria malignant diseases. Liver Transpl 2018; 24 (01) 104-111
  • 3 Kim WR, Lake JR, Smith JM. , et al. OPTN/SRTR 2017 annual data report: liver. Am J Transplant 2019; 19 (Suppl. 02) 184-283
  • 4 Neuberger J. Liver transplantation in the United Kingdom. Liver Transpl 2016; 22 (08) 1129-1135
  • 5 Saidi RF. Utilization of expanded criteria donors in liver transplantation. Int J Organ Transplant Med 2013; 4 (02) 46-59
  • 6 Lindbergh CA. An apparatus for the culture of whole organs. J Exp Med 1935; 62 (03) 409-431
  • 7 Dutkowski P, de Rougemont O, Clavien PA. Alexis Carrel: genius, innovator and ideologist. Am J Transplant 2008; 8 (10) 1998-2003
  • 8 Brettschneider L, Daloze PM, Huguet C. , et al. Successful orthotopic transplantation of liver homografts after eight to twenty-five hours preservation. Surg Forum 1967; 18: 376-378
  • 9 Kestens PJ, Otte JB, Alexandre GP. , et al. [Human orthotopic liver graft]. Acta Chir Belg 1970; 69 (05) 285-303
  • 10 Collins GM, Bravo-Shugarman M, Terasaki PI. Kidney preservation for transportation. Initial perfusion and 30 hours' ice storage. Lancet 1969; 2 (7632): 1219-1222
  • 11 Belzer FO, D'Alessandro AM, Hoffmann RM. , et al. The use of UW solution in clinical transplantation. A 4-year experience. Ann Surg 1992; 215 (06) 579-583 , discussion 584–585
  • 12 Laing RW, Mergental H, Mirza DF. Normothermic ex-situ liver preservation: the new gold standard. Curr Opin Organ Transplant 2017; 22 (03) 274-280
  • 13 Martins PN, Selzner M, Dayangac M. , et al. What is hot and new in basic science in liver transplantation in 2018? report of the Basic Science Committee of the International Liver Transplantation Society. Transplantation 2019; 103 (04) 654-659
  • 14 Taner T, Martins PN, Ling Q. , et al. What is hot and new in basic and translational science in liver transplantation in 2019? Report of the Basic and Translational Research Committee of the International Liver Transplantation Society. Transplantation 2019; 103 (04) 654-659
  • 15 Karangwa SA, Dutkowski P, Fontes P. , et al. Machine perfusion of donor livers for transplantation: a proposal for standardized nomenclature and reporting guidelines. Am J Transplant 2016; 16 (10) 2932-2942
  • 16 Bruinsma BG, Berendsen TA, Izamis ML, Yeh H, Yarmush ML, Uygun K. Supercooling preservation and transplantation of the rat liver. Nat Protoc 2015; 10 (03) 484-494
  • 17 de Vries RJ, Tessier SN, Banik PD. , et al. Supercooling extends preservation time of human livers. Nat Biotechnol 2019; 37 (10) 1131-1136
  • 18 von Horn C, Minor T. Transient hyperthermia during oxygenated rewarming of isolated rat livers. Transpl Int 2020; 33 (03) 272-278
  • 19 Schlegel A, de Rougemont O, Graf R, Clavien PA, Dutkowski P. Protective mechanisms of end-ischemic cold machine perfusion in DCD liver grafts. J Hepatol 2013; 58 (02) 278-286
  • 20 Dutkowski P, Guarrera JV, de Jonge J, Martins PN, Porte RJ, Clavien PA. Evolving trends in machine perfusion for liver transplantation. Gastroenterology 2019; 156 (06) 1542-1547
  • 21 De Carlis R, Lauterio A, Ferla F, Di Sandro S, Sguinzi R, De Carlis L. Hypothermic machine perfusion of liver grafts can safely extend cold Ischemia for Up to 20 hours in cases of necessity. Transplantation 2017; 101 (07) e223-e224
  • 22 Muller X, Schlegel A, Kron P. , et al. Novel real-time prediction of liver graft function during hypothermic oxygenated machine perfusion before liver transplantation. Ann Surg 2019; 270 (05) 783-790
  • 23 Guarrera JV, Henry SD, Samstein B. , et al. Hypothermic machine preservation in human liver transplantation: the first clinical series. Am J Transplant 2010; 10 (02) 372-381
  • 24 De Deken J, Kocabayoglu P, Moers C. Hypothermic machine perfusion in kidney transplantation. Curr Opin Organ Transplant 2016; 21 (03) 294-300
  • 25 Guarrera JV, Henry SD, Samstein B. , et al. Hypothermic machine preservation facilitates successful transplantation of “orphan” extended criteria donor livers. Am J Transplant 2015; 15 (01) 161-169
  • 26 Op den Dries S, Sutton ME, Karimian N. , et al. Hypothermic oxygenated machine perfusion prevents arteriolonecrosis of the peribiliary plexus in pig livers donated after circulatory death. PLoS One 2014; 9 (02) e88521
  • 27 Dutkowski P, Polak WG, Muiesan P. , et al. First comparison of hypothermic oxygenated perfusion versus static cold storage of human donation after cardiac death liver transplants: an international-matched case analysis. Ann Surg 2015; 262 (05) 764-770 , discussion 770–771
  • 28 van Rijn R, Karimian N, Matton APM. , et al. Dual hypothermic oxygenated machine perfusion in liver transplants donated after circulatory death. Br J Surg 2017; 104 (07) 907-917
  • 29 Vekemans K, van Pelt J, Komuta M. , et al. Attempt to rescue discarded human liver grafts by end ischemic hypothermic oxygenated machine perfusion. Transplant Proc 2011; 43 (09) 3455-3459
  • 30 Westerkamp AC, Karimian N, Matton AP. , et al. Oxygenated hypothermic machine perfusion after static cold storage improves hepatobiliary function of extended criteria donor livers. Transplantation 2016; 100 (04) 825-835
  • 31 Burlage LC, Karimian N, Westerkamp AC. , et al. Oxygenated hypothermic machine perfusion after static cold storage improves endothelial function of extended criteria donor livers. HPB (Oxford) 2017; 19 (06) 538-546
  • 32 Brüggenwirth IMA, van Leeuwen OB, de Vries Y. , et al. Extended hypothermic oxygenated machine perfusion enables ex situ preservation of porcine livers for up to 24 hours. JHEP Rep 2020; 2 (02) 100092
  • 33 Guarrera JV, Estevez J, Boykin J. , et al. Hypothermic machine perfusion of liver grafts for transplantation: technical development in human discard and miniature swine models. Transplant Proc 2005; 37 (01) 323-325
  • 34 Schlegel A, Kron P, Dutkowski P. Hypothermic oxygenated liver perfusion: basic mechanisms and clinical application. Curr Transplant Rep 2015; 2 (01) 52-62
  • 35 Abudhaise H, Davidson BR, DeMuylder P, Luong TV, Fuller B. Evolution of dynamic, biochemical, and morphological parameters in hypothermic machine perfusion of human livers: a proof-of-concept study. PLoS One 2018; 13 (09) e0203803
  • 36 Monbaliu D, Liu Q, Libbrecht L. , et al. Preserving the morphology and evaluating the quality of liver grafts by hypothermic machine perfusion: a proof-of-concept study using discarded human livers. Liver Transpl 2012; 18 (12) 1495-1507
  • 37 Lüer B, Koetting M, Efferz P, Minor T. Role of oxygen during hypothermic machine perfusion preservation of the liver. Transpl Int 2010; 23 (09) 944-950
  • 38 Schlegel A, Dutkowski P. Role of hypothermic machine perfusion in liver transplantation. Transpl Int 2015; 28 (06) 677-689
  • 39 Debbaut C, Monbaliu D, Casteleyn C. , et al. From vascular corrosion cast to electrical analog model for the study of human liver hemodynamics and perfusion. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng 2011; 58 (01) 25-35
  • 40 Schlegel A, Kron P, De Oliveira ML, Clavien PA, Dutkowski P. Is single portal vein approach sufficient for hypothermic machine perfusion of DCD liver grafts?. J Hepatol 2016; 64 (01) 239-241
  • 41 Brüggenwirth IMA, Burlage LC, Porte RJ, Martins PN. Is single portal vein perfusion the best approach for machine preservation of liver grafts?. J Hepatol 2016; 64 (05) 1194-1195
  • 42 Jomaa A, Gurusamy K, Siriwardana PN. , et al. Does hypothermic machine perfusion of human donor livers affect risks of sinusoidal endothelial injury and microbial infection? A feasibility study assessing flow parameters, sterility, and sinusoidal endothelial ultrastructure. Transplant Proc 2013; 45 (05) 1677-1683
  • 43 van Leeuwen OB, Fujiyoshi M, Ubbink R. , et al. Ex situ machine perfusion of human donor livers via the surgically reopened umbilical vein: a proof of concept. Transplantation 2019; 103 (10) 2130-2135
  • 44 Jain S, Xu H, Duncan H. , et al. Ex-vivo study of flow dynamics and endothelial cell structure during extended hypothermic machine perfusion preservation of livers. Cryobiology 2004; 48 (03) 322-332
  • 45 Ravikumar R, Jassem W, Mergental H. , et al. Liver transplantation after ex vivo normothermic machine preservation: a Phase 1 (first-in-man) clinical trial. Am J Transplant 2016; 16 (06) 1779-1787
  • 46 Selzner M, Goldaracena N, Echeverri J. , et al. Normothermic ex vivo liver perfusion using Steen solution as perfusate for human liver transplantation: first North American results. Liver Transpl 2016; 22 (11) 1501-1508
  • 47 Bral M, Gala-Lopez B, Bigam D. , et al. Preliminary single-center Canadian experience of human normothermic ex vivo liver perfusion: results of a clinical trial. Am J Transplant 2017; 17 (04) 1071-1080
  • 48 Nasralla D, Coussios CC, Mergental H. , et al; Consortium for Organ Preservation in Europe. A randomized trial of normothermic preservation in liver transplantation. Nature 2018; 557 (7703): 50-56
  • 49 Ghinolfi D, Rreka E, De Tata V. , et al. Pilot, open, randomized, prospective trial for normothermic machine perfusion evaluation in liver transplantation from older donors. Liver Transpl 2019; 25 (03) 436-449
  • 50 Liu Q, Hassan A, Pezzati D. , et al. Ex-situ liver machine perfusion: the impact of fresh frozen plasma. Liver Transpl 2020; 26 (02) 215-226
  • 51 van Leeuwen OB, de Meijer VE, Porte RJ. Viability criteria for functional assessment of donor livers during normothermic machine perfusion. Liver Transpl 2018; 24 (10) 1333-1335
  • 52 Perera T, Mergental H, Stephenson B. , et al. First human liver transplantation using a marginal allograft resuscitated by normothermic machine perfusion. Liver Transpl 2016; 22 (01) 120-124
  • 53 Watson CJ, Kosmoliaptsis V, Randle LV. , et al. Preimplant normothermic liver perfusion of a suboptimal liver donated after circulatory death. Am J Transplant 2016; 16 (01) 353-357
  • 54 Jassem W, Xystrakis E, Ghnewa YG. , et al. Normothermic machine perfusion (NMP) inhibits proinflammatory responses in the liver and promotes regeneration. Hepatology 2019; 70 (02) 682-695
  • 55 Marecki H, Bozorgzadeh A, Porte RJ, Leuvenink HG, Uygun K, Martins PN. Liver ex situ machine perfusion preservation: a review of the methodology and results of large animal studies and clinical trials. Liver Transpl 2017; 23 (05) 679-695
  • 56 op den Dries S, Karimian N, Sutton ME. , et al. Ex vivo normothermic machine perfusion and viability testing of discarded human donor livers. Am J Transplant 2013; 13 (05) 1327-1335
  • 57 Sutton ME, op den Dries S, Karimian N. , et al. Criteria for viability assessment of discarded human donor livers during ex vivo normothermic machine perfusion. PLoS One 2014; 9 (11) e110642
  • 58 Matton APM, de Vries Y, Burlage LC. , et al. Biliary Bicarbonate, pH, and glucose are suitable biomarkers of biliary viability during ex situ normothermic machine perfusion of human donor livers. Transplantation 2019; 103 (07) 1405-1413
  • 59 Karimian N, Matton AP, Westerkamp AC. , et al. Ex situ normothermic machine perfusion of donor livers. J Vis Exp 2015; (99) e52688
  • 60 Vogel T, Brockmann JG, Quaglia A. , et al. The 24-hour normothermic machine perfusion of discarded human liver grafts. Liver Transpl 2017; 23 (02) 207-220
  • 61 Liu Q, Nassar A, Buccini L. , et al. Lipid metabolism and functional assessment of discarded human livers with steatosis undergoing 24 hours of normothermic machine perfusion. Liver Transpl 2018; 24 (02) 233-245
  • 62 Mergental H, Stephenson BTF, Laing RW. , et al. Development of clinical criteria for functional assessment to predict primary nonfunction of high-risk livers using normothermic machine perfusion. Liver Transpl 2018; 24 (10) 1453-1469
  • 63 Mergental H, Perera MT, Laing RW. , et al. Transplantation of declined liver allografts following normothermic ex-situ evaluation. Am J Transplant 2016; 16 (11) 3235-3245
  • 64 Watson CJE, Kosmoliaptsis V, Randle LV. , et al. Normothermic perfusion in the assessment and preservation of declined livers before transplantation: hyperoxia and vasoplegia-important lessons from the first 12 cases. Transplantation 2017; 101 (05) 1084-1098
  • 65 Watson CJE, Kosmoliaptsis V, Pley C. , et al. Observations on the ex situ perfusion of livers for transplantation. Am J Transplant 2018; 18 (08) 2005-2020
  • 66 van Leeuwen OB, de Vries Y, Fujiyoshi M. , et al. Transplantation of high-risk donor livers after ex situ resuscitation and assessment using combined hypo- and normothermic machine perfusion: a prospective clinical trial. Ann Surg 2019; 270 (05) 906-914
  • 67 Laing RW, Mergental H, Yap C. , et al. Viability testing and transplantation of marginal livers (VITTAL) using normothermic machine perfusion: study protocol for an open-label, non-randomised, prospective, single-arm trial. BMJ Open 2017; 7 (11) e017733
  • 68 Boteon YL, Laing RW, Schlegel A. , et al. Combined hypothermic and normothermic machine perfusion improves functional recovery of extended criteria donor livers. Liver Transpl 2018; 24 (12) 1699-1715
  • 69 de Vries Y, Matton APM, Nijsten MWN. , et al. Pretransplant sequential hypo- and normothermic machine perfusion of suboptimal livers donated after circulatory death using a hemoglobin-based oxygen carrier perfusion solution. Am J Transplant 2019; 19 (04) 1202-1211
  • 70 Quintini C, Martins PN, Shah S. , et al; American Society of Transplant Surgeons Standards Committee. Implementing an innovated preservation technology: the American Society of Transplant Surgeons' (ASTS) Standards Committee White Paper on Ex Situ Liver Machine Perfusion. Am J Transplant 2018; 18 (08) 1865-1874
  • 71 Carpenter DJ, Chiles MC, Verna EC. , et al. Deceased brain dead donor liver transplantation and utilization in the United States: nighttime and weekend effects. Transplantation 2019; 103 (07) 1392-1404
  • 72 Sotiropoulos GC, Lang H, Saner FH. , et al. Long-term results after liver transplantation with “livers that nobody wants” within Eurotransplant: a center's experience. Transplant Proc 2008; 40 (09) 3196-3197
  • 73 McCormack L, Quiñonez E, Ríos MM. , et al. Rescue policy for discarded liver grafts: a single-centre experience of transplanting livers ‘that nobody wants’. HPB (Oxford) 2010; 12 (08) 523-530
  • 74 Tector AJ, Mangus RS, Chestovich P. , et al. Use of extended criteria livers decreases wait time for liver transplantation without adversely impacting posttransplant survival. Ann Surg 2006; 244 (03) 439-450
  • 75 Halazun KJ, Quillin RC, Rosenblatt R. , et al. Expanding the margins: high volume utilization of marginal liver grafts among >2000 liver transplants at a single institution. Ann Surg 2017; 266 (03) 441-449
  • 76 Muller X, Marcon F, Sapisochin G. , et al. Defining benchmarks in liver transplantation: a multicenter outcome analysis determining best achievable results. Ann Surg 2018; 267 (03) 419-425
  • 77 Stevens LA, Greene T, Levey AS. Surrogate end points for clinical trials of kidney disease progression. Clin J Am Soc Nephrol 2006; 1 (04) 874-884
  • 78 Agopian VG, Harlander-Locke MP, Markovic D. , et al. Evaluation of early allograft function using the liver graft assessment following transplantation risk score model. JAMA Surg 2018; 153 (05) 436-444
  • 79 Rosen HR, Martin P, Goss J. , et al. Significance of early aminotransferase elevation after liver transplantation. Transplantation 1998; 65 (01) 68-72
  • 80 Feng S, Goodrich NP, Bragg-Gresham JL. , et al. Characteristics associated with liver graft failure: the concept of a donor risk index. Am J Transplant 2006; 6 (04) 783-790
  • 81 Radunz S, Paul A, Nowak K, Treckmann JW, Saner FH, Mathé Z. Liver transplantation using donor organs with markedly elevated liver enzymes: how far can we go?. Liver Int 2011; 31 (07) 1021-1027
  • 82 Gadsden MM, Goldberg DS. Hepatic dysfunction in deceased donors in the age of the opioid epidemic. Transplantation 2018; 102 (10) e403
  • 83 Martins PN, Rawson A, Movahedi B. , et al. Single-center experience with liver transplant using donors with very high transaminase levels. Exp Clin Transplant 2019; 17 (04) 498-506
  • 84 Dufour DR, Lott JA, Nolte FS, Gretch DR, Koff RS, Seeff LB. Diagnosis and monitoring of hepatic injury. II. Recommendations for use of laboratory tests in screening, diagnosis, and monitoring. Clin Chem 2000; 46 (12) 2050-2068
  • 85 Thijssen MF, Brüggenwirth IMA, Gillooly A, Khvorova A, Kowalik TF, Martins PN. Gene Silencing With siRNA (RNA Interference): a new therapeutic option during ex vivo machine liver perfusion preservation. Liver Transpl 2019; 25 (01) 140-151
  • 86 Gillooly AR, Perry J, Martins PN. First Report of siRNA Uptake (for RNA Interference) during ex vivo hypothermic and normothermic liver machine perfusion. Transplantation 2019; 103 (03) e56-e57
  • 87 Bruggenwirth IMA, Martins PN. RNA interference therapeutics in organ transplantation: The dawn of a new era. Am J Transplant 2020; 20 (04) 931-941
  • 88 Buchwald JE, Xu J, Bozorgzadeh A, Martins PN. Therapeutics administered during ex vivo liver machine perfusion: An overview. World J Transplant 2020; 10 (01) 1-14
  • 89 Yao CG, Martins PN. Nanotechnology Applications in Transplantation Medicine. Transplantation 2020; 104 (04) 682-693