RSS-Feed abonnieren
DOI: 10.1055/s-0039-1678596
Safe Storage of Gametes and Embryos: No Time for Complacency
Publikationsverlauf
Publikationsdatum:
04. April 2019 (online)
Abstract
Recent serious untoward incidents in the field of assisted reproduction have once again highlighted the need for vigilance and in particular improved risk management in relation to the cryopreservation of gametes and embryos. Despite increasing levels of regulation and the requirement to adhere to total quality management practices, catastrophic incidents such as the death of an employee or the loss of a freezer full of patient embryos or sperm continue to occur sufficiently frequently for the industry to be concerned and highlight the need to make practices considerably safer. Potential losses through litigation could be considerable if the gamete or embryo bank is found to be negligent and fails to provide the necessary resources and implement recognizable control measures, which may include suitable facilities with adequate ventilation and oxygen monitoring, competent staff, and an appropriate level of well-maintained equipment; round-the-clock emergency procedures, early warning systems to deal with a failing vessel; and contingency to mitigate losses within a failing vessel and validated procedures which are embedded into the organization which lead to a high-quality end product, for example, frozen embryo while permitting a safe system of work. Since cross-contamination incidents have occurred in other disciplines such as blood cryostorage, which have led to the transmission of viral disease, the biological safety of the end product also requires careful consideration despite the fact that no similar incident appears to have come to light in the field of reproductive medicine. Implementation of risk reduction measures may include screening for blood borne viruses and possibly bacterial infection, careful selection of appropriate packaging plastics, and consideration as to whether packaging is suitable for immersion in liquid nitrogen. If not, vapor phase storage may be considered as additional mitigation. In the light of recent events, centers should place risk management of their cryofacilities and service high on the agenda and ensure that it becomes integral to future objective setting and business planning.
-
References
- 1 Tomlinson MJ, Sakkas D. Debate Article: Safe and effective cryopreservation: Should sperm banks and fertility centres move toward storage in nitrogen vapour?. Hum Reprod 2000; 15: 2460-2463
- 2 News BBC. Safety problems led to lab death 2000; http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/scotland/798925.stm . Accessed February 19, 2019
- 3 Health and Safety Executive. NHS Trust and Imperial College London fined after death of worker 2017; http://press.hse.gov.uk/2017/nhs-trust-and-imperial-college-london-fined-after-death-of-worker/ . Accessed May 9, 2018
- 4 Owen-Jones J. Airgas’ improper safety procedures led to fatal gas leak. 2017; https://www.gasworld.com/causes-of-airgas-liquid-nitrogen-leak-revealed-/2013316.article . Accessed 5/9/18. 14:35
- 5 News BBC. Freezer fault hits sperm bank. 2002; http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/2284619.stm . Accessed 6/9/18, 19.35
- 6 The Scotsman. Sperm bank disaster cover up claim. 2002; https://www.scotsman.com /news/sperm-bank-disaster-cover-up-claim-1-607139 . Accessed June 9, 2018
- 7 News BBC. Cancer sperm men win court battle 2002; http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/bristol/7869347.stm . Accessed July 9, 2018
- 8 HFEA. Chair’s letter07/06/2004 - CH(04)03 https://portal.hfea.gov.uk/knowledge-base/chairs-letters/748 . Accessed June 9, 2018
- 9 News BBC. Rules to safeguard IVF samples. 2004; http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/3786407.stm . Accessed June 9, 2018
- 10 CBC News. Who’s responsible when a sperm freezer defrosts? 2013; http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/who-s-responsible-when-a-sperm-freezer-defrosts-1.2436461 . Accessed May 9, 2018
- 11 Meryman HT. Preservation of living cells. Fed Proc 1963; 22: 81-89
- 12 Miller AA. Glass-Transition Temperature of Water. Science 1969; 21 (163) 1325-1326
- 13 Giovambattista N, Austen Angell C, Sciortino F, Stanley HE. Glass-Transition Temperature of Water: A Simulation Study. Phys Rev Lett 2004; 93: 047801
- 14 National Post Canada. Sperm recognized as property in B.C. case; donors win $6.2M settlement. 2015; https://nationalpost.com/news/canada/spermrecognized-as-property-in-b-c-case-donors-win-6-2m-settlement . Accessed May 9, 2018
- 15 CBS News. 2nd fertility clinic has freezer failure, jeopardizing thousands of frozen eggs and embryos. 2018. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/2nd-fertility-clinic-has-freezer-failure-jeopardizing-thousands-of-frozen-eggs-and-embryos/ . Accessed June 9, 2018
- 16 Buduson S. Human error blamed for Ohio fertility center malfunction, says 4,000 eggs and embryos lost. WXYZ Detroit. 2018; Retrieved from https://www.wxyz.com/news/national/ human-error-blamed-for-ohio-fertility-center-malfunction-says-4000-eggs-and-embryos-lost . Accessed June 9, 2018
- 17 Tomlinson MJ, Pacey AA. Practical Aspects of Sperm Banking for Cancer. Hum Fertil 2003; 6: 100-105
- 18 Jaycock C, Brown R. RPC Medical Update.Consequence of failed sperm storage. 2011; at https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=3bdc24da-967c-4fc6-b2af-feadd91b25ee . Accessed May 9, 2018
- 19 Puchta A. Human Sperm to Constitute Legal Property: Lam v University of British Columbia. 2015; Found at: http://www.thecourt.ca/human-sperm-to-constitute-legal-property-lam-v-university-of-british-columbia/ . Accessed May 9, 2018
- 20 Tomlinson MJ, Harbottle SJ. Facilities and Resources for the Andrology Service (book chapter 8). A practical guide to setting up and running an IVF lab, embryo culture systems and running the unit. 2013. Jaypee Brothers Medical Publishers Ltd. 69-86
- 21 Pomeroy KO. Liquid nitrogen storage tank failure: Can we improve the current system? 2018; https://www.fertstertdialog.com/users/16110-fertility-and-sterility/posts/33372-pomeroy-consider-this . Accessed August 21, 2018
- 22 Balshaw NH. Practical Cryogenics an Introduction to Laboratory Cryogenics By N H Balshaw. 2001; Published by Oxford Instruments Superconductivity Limited. Found at: https://docplayer.net/21319927-Practical-cryogenics-an-introduction-to-laboratory-cryogenics-by-n-h-balshaw.html . Accessed January 30, 2019
- 23 Srinivasan KV. , Hedukar A Re-evacuation, Repair and Revival Techniques of Cryogenic Dewars. Engineering and Technology 2017; 4 (06) 76-81 http://www.aascit.org/journal/et ISSN: 2381-1072. Accessed January 30, 2019
- 24 European Commission. Directive 2004/23/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 31 March 2004 on setting standards of quality and safety for the donation, procurement, testing, processing, preservation, storage and distribution of human tissues and cells. 2004; Official Journal of the European Union 102, 07/04/2004 P. 0048 - 0058
- 25 Human Tissue Authority The Human Tissue (Quality and Safety for Human Application). (Amendment) Regulations. 2018. Found at https://www.legislation.gov.uk /ukdsi/2018/9780111163450/contents. Accessed July 9, 2018
- 26 Connor T. 40 men sue hospital after accidental thaw destroyed sperm. 2015; NBC News / Nov.02.2015 / 11:44 PM ET /Found at: https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/40-men-sue-hospital-after-accidental-thaw-destroyed-sperm-flna6C10971045 . Accessed April 9, 2018
- 27 Manchir M. Lawsuits filed over malfunction at sperm bank 2013; http://articles.chicagotribune.com/2013-08-20/news/chi-lawsuits-filed-over-malfunction-at-sperm-bank-20130820_1_sperm-bank-malfunction-matthew-jenkins . Accessed May 9, 2018
- 28 Pfaff, Gill & Ports. First Settlement in sperm loss cases at Northwestern. 2015; Found at https://www.pfaffgill.com/blog/2015/06/first-settlement-in-sperm-loss-cases-at-northwestern.shtml
- 29 British Compressed Gas Association (BCGA). 2013, http://www.bcga.co.uk/pages/index.cfm?pageid=111
- 30 Mortimer D. Symposium: Cryopreservation and assisted human conception Current and future concepts and practices in human sperm cryobanking. 2004; RBM online 2004; 9, No 2. 134–151
- 31 Tomlinson MJ. Opinion: managing risk associated with cryopreservation. Hum Reprod 2005; 20: 1751-1756
- 32 Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority. HFEA Code of Practice 8th Edition 2014
- 33 Tomlinson MJ, Morroll D. Risks associated with cryopreservation: a survey of assisted conception units in the UK and Ireland. Hum Fertil 2008; 11: 33-42
- 34 Lopes AS, Frederickx V, Van Kerkhoven G, Campo R, Puttemans P, Gordts S. Survival, re-expansion and cell survival of human blastocysts following vitrification and warming using two vitrification systems. J Assist Reprod Genet 2015; 32 (01) 83-90
- 35 Gook DA, Choo B, Bourne H, Lewis K, Edgar DH. Closed vitrification of human oocytes and blastocysts: outcomes from a series of clinical cases. J Assist Reprod Genet 2016; 33: 1247-1252
- 36 Sherman JK, Bunge RG. Observations on preservation of human spermatozoa at low temperatures. Proc Soc Exp Biol Med 1953; 82: 686-688
- 37 Perloff WH, Steinberger E, Sherman JK. Conception with human spermatozoa frozen by nitrogen vapor technique. Fertil Steril 1964; 15: 501-504
- 38 Critser JK, Huse-Benda AR, Aaker DV, Arneson BW, Ball GD. Cryopreservation of human spermatozoa: I. Effects of holding procedure and seeding motility, fertilizability, and acrosome reaction. Fertil Steril 1987; 47: 656-663
- 39 Gao DY, Liu J, Liu C. , et al. Prevention of osmotic injury to human spermatozoa during addition and removal of glycerol. Hum Reprod 1995; 10: 1109-1122
- 40 Gilmore JA, Liu J, Gao DY, Critser JK. Determination of optimal cryoprotectants and procedures for their addition and removal from human spermatozoa. Hum Reprod 1997; 12: 112-118
- 41 Ozkavukcu S, Erdemli E, Isik A. Derya Oztuna and Sercin Karahuseyinoglu. Effects of cryopreservation on sperm parameters and ultrastructural morphology of human spermatozoa. J Assist Reprod Genet 2008; 25 (08) 403-411
- 42 Tomlinson MJ, Pooley K, Pierce A, Hopkisson JF. Sperm donor recruitment within an NHS fertility service since the removal of anonymity. Hum Fertil 2010; 13: 159-167
- 43 Badenoch DF, Moore HD, Holt WV. et al. Sperm motility, velocity and migration. Br J Urol 1990; 65: 204-208
- 44 Tomlinson MJ, Naeem A. Computer-aided sperm analysis (CASA) in the medical laboratory: CASA in diagnostic andrology and assisted conception. 2018. Reprod Fertil Dev 10.1071/RD17520 [Epub ahead of print]
- 45 Keel BA, Stembridge TW, Pineda G, Serafy Sr NT. Lack of standardization in performance of the semen analysis among laboratories in the United States. Fertil Steril 2002; 78: 603-608
- 46 Brazil C, Swan SS, Tollner CR, Treece C. , et al. Quality control of laboratory methods for semen evaluation in a multicenter research study. J Androl 2004; 24: 645-656
- 47 Tomlinson MJ. Debate: Uncertainty of measurement and clinical value of semen analysis: Has standardisation through professional guidelines helped or hindered progress?. Andrology 2016; 4 (05) 763-770
- 48 Tomlinson MJ, Comajuan E, Naeem A, Pooley K. Standards in reporting cryopreserved donor sperm characteristics: Should they be reported post thaw or post wash?. RBMonline 2016; 33 (01) 111-113
- 49 Kelleher S, Wishart SM, Liu PY, Turner L, Di Pierro I, Conway AJ, Handelsman DJ. Long-term outcomes of elective human sperm cryostorage. Hum Reprod 2001; 16: 2632-2639
- 50 Van Casteren NJ, Boellaard WP, Romijn JC, Dohle GR. Gonadal dysfunction in male cancer patients before cytotoxic treatment. Int J Androl 2010; 33: 73-79
- 51 Tomlinson MJ, Meadows J, Kohut Z. , et al. Review and follow-up of patients using a regional sperm cryopreservation service: ensuring that resources are targeted to those patients most in need. Andrology 2015; 3: 709-716
- 52 Vitthala S, Gelbaya TA, Hunter H, Roberts SA, Nardo LG. Stimulated intrauterine insemination (SIUI) and donor insemination (DI) as first line management for a selected subfertile population: the Manchester experience. J Assist Reprod Genet 2008; 25 (9–10): 431-436
- 53 Gudipati M, Pearce K, Prakash A. , et al. The sperm donor programme over 11 years at Newcastle Fertility Centre. Hum Fertil (Camb) 2013; 16 (04) 258-265
- 54 Thijssen A, Creemers A, Van der Elst W. , et al. Predictive factors influencing pregnancy rates after intrauterine insemination with frozen donor semen: a prospective cohort study. RBM Online 2017; 34: 590-597
- 55 Tedder RS, Zuckerman MA, Goldstone AH. , et al. Hepatitis B transmission from contaminated cryopreservation tank. Lancet 1995; 15: 137-140
- 56 Executive NHS. Guidance notes on the processing, storage and issue of bone marrow and blood stem cells. 1997; Department of Health. United Kingdom
- 57 Alberda AT, van Os HC, Zeilmaker GH, Rothbarth PH, Heijtink RA, Schalm SW. Hepatitis B virus infection in women treated with in-vitro fertilization. Ned Tijdschr Geneeskd 1989; 133 (01) 20-25
- 58 Larman MG, Hashimoto S, Morimoto Y, Gardner DK. Cryopreservation in ART and concerns with contamination during cryobanking. Reprod Med Biol 2014; 13 (03) 107-117
- 59 Joaquim DC, Borges ED, Viana IGR, Navarro PA, Vireque AA. Risk of contamination of gametes and embryos during cryopreservation and measures to prevent cross-contamination. 2017 ; BioMed Res Int 1840417
- 60 Vajta G, Rienzi L, Ubaldi FM. Open versus closed systems for vitrification of human oocytes and embryos. 2015 ; Reprod Biomed Online 30, 325–333
- 61 Papatheodorou A, Vanderzwalmen P, Panagiotidis Y, Prapas N, Zikopoulos K, Georgiou I, Prapas Y. Open versus closed oocyte vitrification system: a prospective randomized sibling-oocyte study. Reprod Biomed Online 2013; 26 (06) 595-602
- 62 De Munck N, Vajta G. Safety and efficiency of oocyte vitrification. Cryobiology 2017; 78: 119-127
- 63 Nicastri E, Castilletti C, Liuzzi G, Iannetta M, Capobianchi MR, Ippolito G. Persistent detection of Zika virus RNA in semen for six months after symptom onset in a traveller returning from Haiti to Italy, Euro Surveill. 2016; 11;21(32), 1ߝ4
- 64 American Industrial Hygiene Association. (AIHA) Lab Safety Cryogens Incidents. https://www.aiha.org/get-involved/VolunteerGroups/LabHSCommittee/ Incident%20 Pages/Lab-Safety-Cryogens-Incidents.aspx . Accessed 6/9/18. 19:00
- 65 Clarke G. Sperm cryopreservation: is there a significant risk of cross-contamination?. Hum Reprod 1999; 14: 2941-2943
- 66 Gilling-Smith C, Almeida P. ; Practice and Policy Committee of the British Fertility Society. HIV, hepatitis B and hepatitis C and infertility: reducing risk. Hum Fertil (Camb) 2003; 6 (03) 106-112
- 67 Biddulph MW. Cryogenic embrittlement of steel. Conservation & Recycling 1977; 1 (02) 221-230
- 68 Keseler H, Westermann I, Kandukuri SY, N⊘kleby JO, Holmedal B. Permanent effect of a cryogenic spill on fracture properties of structural steels. IOP Conf. Ser.: Mater. Sci. Eng. 2015; 102: 012004
- 69 Fountain D, Ralston M, Higgins N. , et al. Liquid nitrogen freezers: a potential source of microbial contamination of hematopoietic stem cell components. Transfusion 1997; 37 (06) 585-591
- 70 Grout BW, Morris GJ. Contaminated liquid nitrogen vapour as a risk factor in pathogen transfer. Theriogenology 2009; 15 (71) 1079-1082
- 71 Bielanski A. Non-transmission of bacterial and viral microbes to embryos and semen stored in the vapour phase of liquid nitrogen in dry shippers. Cryobiology 2005; 50 (02) 206-210
- 72 Maertens A, Bourlet T, Plotton N, Pozzetto B, Levy R. Validation of safety procedures for the cryopreservation of semen contaminated with hepatitis C virus in assisted reproductive technology. Hum Reprod 2004; 19 (07) 1554-1557
- 73 Adam M, Hu JF, Lange P, Wolfinbarger Jr L. The effect of liquid nitrogen submersion on cryopreserved human heart valves. Cryobiology 1990; 27: 605-614
- 74 Unger C, Skottman H, Blomberg P, Dilber MS, Hovatta O. Good manufacturing practice and clinical-grade human embryonic stem cell lines. Hum Mol Genet 2008; 17 (R1): R48-53
- 75 Amesse LS, Srivastava G, Uddin D, Pfaff-Amesse T. Comparison of cryopreserved sperm in vaporous and liquid nitrogen. J Reprod Med 2003; 48: 224-319
- 76 Eum JH, Park JK, Lee WS, Cha KR, Yoon TK, Lee DR. Long term liquid nitrogen vapor storage of mouse embryos cryopreserved using vitrification or slow cooling. Fertil Steril 2009; 91 (05) 1928-1932
- 77 Cobo A, Romero JL, Pérez S, de los Santos MJ, Meseguer M, Remohí J. Storage of human oocytes in the vapor phase of nitrogen. Fertil Steril 2010; 94 (05) 1903-1907