We compared the Ivy bleeding time method and two alternatives of the Simplate II® method (incisions in horizontal and vertical direction) with each other, with regard to the sensitivity, the specificity, the costs and the burden for the patient. In the aspirin study an aspirin-induced bleeding defect was used. Seventy-two healthy volunteers were randomized to receive either 500 mg acetylsalicylic acid (ASA) or a placebo. Double blinding was maintained throughout the study. In the anticoagulation study 62 patients participated, who received oral anticoagulants (OAC) for various reasons. All participants received two bleeding time methods. The burden for the participants of each method was screened by a small standard questionnaire.
The differences in sensitivity and specificity between the three methods proved minimal. The Ivy method was more often preferred by the participants than the Simplate methods.
Since a choice on the basis of sensitivity and specificity appears not possible, we prefer the Ivy method because of lower costs and less burden.
References
1
Duke WW.
The relation of blood platelets to hemorrhagic disease: description of a method for determining the bleeding time and coagulation time and report of three cases of hemorrhagic disease relieved by transfusion. JAMA 1910; 55: 1185-1192
3
Ivy AC,
Nelson D,
Bucher G.
The standardization of certain factors in the cutaneous “venostasis” bleeding time technique. J Lab Clin Med 1941; 26: 1812-1822
4
Mielke Jr CH,
Kaneshiro MM,
Maher IA,
Weiner JM,
Rapaport SI.
The standardized normal Ivy bleeding time and its prolongation by aspirin. Blood 1969; 34: 204-215
5
Koster T,
Caekebeke-Peerlinck KMJ,
Briet E.
A randomized and blinded comparison of the sensitivity and the reproducibility of the Ivy and Simplate II® bleeding time techniques. Am J Clin Pathol 1989; 92: 315-320
7
Buchanan GR,
Holtkamp CA.
A comparative study of variables affecting the bleeding time using two disposable devices. Am J Clin Pathol 1989; 91: 45-51
8
Smith PS,
Baglini R,
Meissner GF.
The prolonged bleeding time in hemophilia A: comparison of two measuring technics and clinical associations. Am J Clin Pathol 1985; 83: 211-215
9
Marongiu F,
Biondi G,
Sorano GG,
Mameli G,
Conti M,
Mamusa AM,
Cadoni MC,
Balestrieri A.
Bleeding time is prolonged during oral anticoagulant therapy. Thromb Res 1990; 59: 905-912
20
Macherel P,
Sulzer I,
Furlan M,
Lammle B.
Warning: Simplate II -Lack of standardization in standardized bleeding time devices. Thromb Haemostas 1990; 64: 605
