Metabolic Profiling of Echinacea Genotypes and a Test of Alternative Taxonomic Treatments

Abstract

The genus Echinacea is used as an herbal medicine to treat a variety of ailments. To better understand its potential chemical variation, 40 Echinacea accessions encompassing broad geographical and morphological diversity were evaluated under controlled conditions. Metabolites of roots from these accessions were analyzed by HPLC-photo diode array (HPLC-PDA), GC-MS, and multivariate statistical methods. In total, 43 lipophilic metabolites, including 24 unknown compounds, were detected. Weighted principal component analysis (WPCA) and clustering analysis of the levels of these metabolites across Echinacea accessions, based on Canberra distances, allowed us to test two alternative taxonomic treatments of the genus, with the further goal of facilitating accession identification. A widely used system developed by McGregor based primarily on morphological features was more congruent with the dendrogram generated from the lipophilic metabolite data than the system more recently developed by Binns et al. Our data support the hypothesis that Echinacea pallida is a diverse allopolyploid, incorporating the genomes of Echinacea simulata and another taxon, possibly Echinacea sanguinea. Finally, most recognized taxa of Echinacea can be identified by their distinct lipophilic metabolite fingerprints.

Key words

Echinacea (Asteraceae) - alkamides - alkylamides - HPLC - GC-MS - PCA

References

• 1 Greger H. Alkamides: Structural relationships, distribution and biological activity [Asteraceae, Heliantheae, Anthemideae].  Planta Med. 1984;  50 366-75
• 2 Foster S. Echinacea: Nature's immune enhancer. Rochester; Healing Arts Press 1991: 20-3
• 3 Jackson J B. Toothache medicine: A customary use of pale purple coneflower (Echinacea pallida (Nutt.) Nutt.) among the Yuchi in eastern Oklahoma, USA.  Econ Bot. 2006;  60 386-8
• 4 Yu H, Kaarlas M. Popularity, diversity, and quality of Echinacea. In: Miller SC, editor Echinacea: The genus Echinacea. Boca Raton; CRC Press 2004: 127-49
• 5 Bauer R. Echinacea: Biological effects and active principles. In: Lawson LD, Bauer R, editors Phytomedicines of Europe: chemistry and biological activity. Washington, DC; American Chemical Society Symposium Series 691. ACS 1998: 140-57
• 6 Linde K, Barrett B, Wolkart K, Bauer R, Melchart D. Echinacea for preventing and treating the common cold.  Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2006;  25 CD000530
• 7 Barnes J, Anderson L A, Gibbons S, Phillipson J D. Echinacea species (Echinacea angustifolia (DC.) Hell., Echinacea pallida (Nutt.) Nutt., Echinacea purpurea (L.) Moench): A review of their chemistry, pharmacology and clinical properties.  J Pharm Pharmacol. 2005;  57 929-54
• 8 Binns S E, Livesey J F, Arnason J T, Baum B R. Phytochemical variation in Echinacea Moench (Helianthese: Asteraceae) from roots and flowerheads of wild and cultivated populations.  J Agric Food Chem. 2002;  50 3673-87
• 9 McGregor R L. The taxonomy of the genus Echinacea (Compositae).  Univ Kansas Sci Bull. 1968;  68 113-42
• 10 Baum B R, Binns S E, Arnason J T. Integrating recent knowledge about the genus Echinacea: Morphology, molecular systematics, phytochemistry.  Herbal Gram. 2006;  72 32-46
• 11 Blumenthal M, Urbatsch L E. Echinacea taxonomy – is the re-classification of the genus warranted?.  Herbal Gram. 2006;  72 30-1, 80
• 12 Urbatsch L E, Neubig K M, Cox P B. Echinacea Moench, Methodus. In: Flora of North America.  eFloras.org. 2006;  21 43, 64-5, 88
• 13 Binns S E, Baum B R, Arnason J T. A taxonomic revision of the genus Echinacea (Heliantheae; Asteraceae).  Syst Bot. 2002;  27 610-32
• 14 Mechanda S M, Baum B R, Johnson D A, Arnason J T. Analysis of diversity of natural populations and commercial lines of Echinacea using AFLP.  Can J Bot. 2004;  82 461-84
• 15 Kim D H, Heber D, Still D W. Genetic diversity of Echinacea species based on amplified fragment length polymorphism markers.  Genome. 2004;  47 102-11
• 16 Flagel L, Rapp R A, Grover C E, Widrlechner M P, Hawkins J, Grafenberg J L. et al . Phylogenetic, morphological, and chemotaxonomic incongruence in the North American endemic genus Echinacea Moench.  Am J Bot. 2008;  95 756-65
• 17 Wu L, Bae J, Kraus G, Wurtele E S. Diacetylenic isobutylamides of Echinacea: synthesis and natural distribution.  Phytochemistry. 2004;  65 2477-84
• 18 Kraus G A, Bae J, Wu L, Wurtele E S. Synthesis and natural distribution of anti-inflammatory alkamides from Echinacea. .  Molecules. 2006;  11 758-67
• 19 Kraus G A, Bae J, Wu L, Wurtele E S. The synthesis and natural distribution of the major ketone constituents in Echinacea pallida. .  Molecules. 2007;  12 406-14
• 20 Digby P G, Kempton R A. Multivariate analysis of ecological communities. New York; Chapman and Hall/Methuen 1987
• 21 Widrlechner M P, McKeown K A. Assembling and characterizing a comprehensive Echinacea germplasm collection. In: Janick J, Whipkey A, editors Trends and new crops and new uses. Alexandria; ASHS Press 2002: 506-8
• 22 Senchina D S, Wu L, Flinn G N, Konopka D E, McCoy J A, Widrlechner M P. et al . Year-and-a-half old, dried Echinacea spp. roots retain cytokine-modulating capabilities in an in vitro human older adult model of influenza vaccination.  Planta Med. 2006;  72 1207-15
• 23 Bauer R, Remiger P. TLC and HPLC analysis of alkamides in Echinacea drugs.  Planta Med. 1989;  55 367-71
• 24 Molgaard P, Johnsen S, Christensen P, Cornett C. HPLC method validated for the simultaneous analysis of cichoric acid and alkamides in Echinacea purpurea plants and products.  J Agric Food Chem. 2003;  51 6922-33
• 25 Chen Y, Fu T, Tao T, Yang J, Chang Y, Wang M. et al . Macrophage activating effects of new alkamides from the roots of Echinacea species.  J Nat Prod. 2005;  68 773-6
• 26 Senchina D S, Flagel L E, Wendel J F, Kohut M L. Phenetic comparison of seven Echinacea species based on immunomodulatory characteristics.  Econ Bot. 2006;  60 205-11