D-Dimer Test and Diagnosis of Deep Vein Thrombosis: A Comparative Study of 7 Assays

Summary

The current D-Dimer ELISA methods provide high sensitivity and negative predictive value for the diagnosis of deep vein thrombosis but these methods are not suitable for emergency or for individual determination. We have evaluated the performance of 3 newly available fast D-Dimer assays (Vidas D-Di, BioMerieux; Instant IA D-Di, Stago; Nycocard D-Dimer, Nycomed) in comparison with 3 classic ELISA methods (Stago, Organon, Behring) and a Latex agglutination technique (Stago). One-hundred-and-seventy-one patients suspected of presenting a first episode of deep vein thrombosis were investigated. A deep vein thrombosis was detected in 75 patients (43.8%) by ultrasonic duplex scanning of the lower limbs; in 11 of them the thrombi were distal and very limited in size (<2 cm). We compared the performance of the tests by calculating their sensitivity, specificity, positive and negative predictive value for different cut-off levels and by calculating the area under ROC curves. The concordance of the different methods was evaluated by calculating the kappa coefficient. The performances of the 3 classic ELISA and of the Vidas D-Di were comparable and kappa coefficients indicated a good concordance between the results provided by these assays. Their sensitivity slightly declined for detection of the very small thrombi. Instant IA D-Di had a non-significantly lower sensitivity and negative predictive value than the 4 previous assays; however its performance was excellent for out-patients. As expected, the Latex assay had too low a sensitivity and negative predictive value to be recommended. In our hands, Nycocard D-Dimer also exhibited low sensitivity and negative predictive value, which were significantly improved when the plasma samples were tested by the manufacturer. Thus significant progress has been made, allowing clinical studies to be planned to compare the safety and cost-effectiveness of D-Dimer strategy to those of the conventional methods for the diagnosis of venous thrombosis.

• References

• 1 Bounameaux H, de Moerloose P, Perrier A, Reber G. Plasma measurement of D-Dimer as diagnostic aid in suspected venous thromboembolism: an overview. Thromb Haemost 1994; 71: 1-6
• 2 Elias A. Place de l’echographie doppler dans le diagnostic des thromboses veineuses. Arch Mai Coeur 1991; 84: 1669-1678
• 3 Gostad GO, Dale S, Brosstad F, Brandsnes O, Holtlund J, Mork E, Gartner E, Borch SM. Assay of D-dimer based on immunofiltration and staining with gold colloids. Clin Chem 1993; 39: 2070-2076
• 4 Vissac AM, Grimaux M, Chartier S, Chan FA, Chambrette B, Amiral J. A new sensitive membrane based Elisa technique for instantaneous D-dimer evaluation in emergency. Thromb Res 1995; 78: 341-352
• 5 Sackett DL, Haynes RB, Tugwell P. Clinical Epidemiology. A Basic Science for Clinical Medicine. First edition Little Brown and Company; Boston: 1985: 59-138
• 6 Metz CE. Basic principles of ROC analysis. Semin Nucl Med 1978; 8: 383-398
• 7 Hanley JA, McNeil BJ. A method of compariing the areas under receiver operating characteristic curves derived from the same cases. Radiology 1983; 148: 839-843
• 8 Fermanian J. Mesure de 1’accord entre deux juges. Cas qualitatif. Rev Epidem et Sante Publ 1984; 32: 140-147
• 9 Elias A, Lecorff G, Bouvier JL, Benichou M, Serradimigni A. Value of real time B mode ultrasound of deep vein thrombosis of the lower limbs. Int Angiol 1987; 6: 175-182
• 10 Lensing AW, Prandoni P, Brandjes D. Detection of deep vein thrombosis by real time B mode ultrasonography. N Engl J Med 1989; 320: 342-345
• 11 Raimondi P, Bongard O, de Moerloose P, Reber G, Waldvogel F, Bounameaux H. D-Dimer plasma concentration in various clinical conditions: implication for the use of this test in the diagnostic approach of venous thromboembolism. Thromb Res 1993; 69: 125-130
• 12 Ellis DR, Eaton AS, Plank MC, Butman BT, Ebert RF. A comparative evaluation of ELISAs for D-Dimer and related fibrin(ogen) degradation products. Blood Coag Fibrinol 1993; 4: 537-549
• 13 Bronner J, Drouin B, Sartre J, Dupuy G, Pittet JL, Le Louem J. Vidas D-Dimer: a new system for the assay of D-Dimer in emergency. Thromb Haemost 1995; 73: 1101 (abst.)
• 14 Baillart O, Soria C, Kedra A, Duet M, Benelhadj S, Dupuy E, Zini C, Kedra N, Mouliade C, Vissac AM, Amiral J, Drouet L, Mundler O. The use of a new D-Dimer assay, Instant I.A. D-Dimers, is suitable for emergency diagnosis of deep vein thrombosis (DVT) or pulmonary embolism (PE). Thromb Haemost 1995; 73: 1098 (abst.)
• 15 Moerloose de Ph, Vissac AM, Reber G, Bounameaux H, Amiral J. A new, semi-quantitative and individual ELISA assays for rapid measurement of plasma D-Dimer in patients suspected of venous thromboembolism. Blood Coag Fibrinol 1995; 6: 460-463
• 16 Dale S, Gogstad GO, Brosstad F, Godal HC, Holtlund J, Mork E, Brandsnes O, Borch SM. Comparison of three D-Dimer assays for the diagnosis of DVT: ELISA, Latex and an immunofiltration assay (Nycocard D-Dimer). Thromb Haemost 1994; 71: 270-274
• 17 Ginsberg JS, Wells PS, Brill-Edwards P, Donovan D, Panju A, van Beek EJR, Patel A. Application of a novel and rapid whole blood assay for D-Dimer in patients clinically suspected pulmonary embolism. Thromb Haemost 1995; 73: 35-38
• 18 Brenner B, Pery M, Lanir N, Jabareen A, Markel A, Kaftori JK, Gaitini D, Rylatt D. Application of a bedside whole blood D-Dimer assay in the diagnosis of deep vein thrombosis. Blood Coag Fibrinol 1995; 6: 219-222